Gauhati High Court Says Wife’s Social Media Posts Of Enjoying Life Do Not Prove Financial Capability

5 min read

Wife’s Social Media Posts about an “enjoyable life at Guwahati” do not prove she could finance her lifestyle through employment, the Gauhati High Court has held, setting aside a Family Court order that denied her maintenance and directing the husband to pay Rs 2,000 a month.

Gauhati High Court building, where a Division Bench held a wife’s social media posts do not prove her financial capability.

Guwahati: A wife who posted on social media about her “enjoyable life at Guwahati” cannot be refused maintenance on that ground, the Gauhati High Court has held. Setting aside the Family Court’s order, it said the posts do not show she was able to finance her lifestyle through employment, and granted her Rs 2,000 a month from November 2026 [Wife v. Husband (names withheld), Crl.Rev.P. No. 374 of 2026].

The judgment was pronounced on November 18, 2026, after being reserved on November 11, by a Division Bench of Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma. Justice Zothankhuma authored it.

The finding on the posts

“The finding of the learned Family Court that the petitioner-wife is having an “enjoyable life at Guwahati” as uploaded by her on social media does not, in our view, prove that the petitioner-wife was able to finance her lifestyle through employment.”

The Bench did note the wife’s own affidavit of October 8, 2026, in which she stated that she was working as a saleswoman with Lavaniya Trade & Agencies. She could therefore maintain herself to a certain degree, the Court said, but was entitled to some more maintenance so that she could have the lifestyle she was used to before the separation.

The charge that she left

Each side had alleged extramarital relationships against the other, and neither party proved the allegation. Nothing in the pleadings showed that the wife refused to live with her husband. Neither side had filed for restitution of conjugal rights or for divorce, and nothing showed she was unwilling to resume married life.

How the dispute reached the High Court

The couple married on March 9, 2023 according to Hindu rites and separated about three months later. The wife applied for maintenance under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS). On May 18, 2026, the Principal Judge, Family Court, Nalbari dismissed the application in Case No. 82 of 2025.

The Family Court’s reasons were that she had not explained how she was financing the lifestyle visible from her social media posts, that as an able-bodied person she could not plead inability to maintain herself only because she was without work, and that she appeared to have left the matrimonial home voluntarily. It held that Section 144(4) BNSS disentitled her because she had not returned to live with her husband.

What each side said

Counsel for the wife, D. Pathak, submitted that she had earlier worked with Lavaniya Trade & Agencies but was no longer employed. The wife claimed Rs 15,000 a month and asserted that the husband earned Rs 50,000 a month, owned a pig farm and had considerable land.

Counsel S. Paul appeared for the husband. His affidavit of assets and liabilities showed a salary of Rs 14,007.10 from V Mart Retail Limited.

Working out the incomes

Relying on Rajnesh v. Neha, the Court said every party must make a full and truthful disclosure of income and an adverse inference may be drawn when they do not. It found the husband’s actual income was likely higher than his salary, since he had taken a personal loan of Rs 40,000 to Rs 50,000 and had bought and sold a goods vehicle, and he had not explained how he repaid the loan or the income from a shop he was said to own. The wife’s claims about his Rs 50,000 income, pig farm and land were not backed by any document.

The Bench took the husband’s income from all sources at Rs 18,000 a month, accounting for his loan and the fact that he lives with his parents, and the wife’s at Rs 7,500. Though the gap was not large, it did not consider it appropriate to deny her maintenance. The Court also cited Chaturbhuj v. Sita Bai on the purpose of preventing destitution and Deepa Joshi v. Gaurav Joshi on loan repayments not taking precedence over maintenance, noting that roughly 25 per cent of a husband’s net income is a broad guideline and not a rule of law.

The directions

From November 2026, the husband must pay Rs 2,000 a month into the wife’s account by the 7th of each month. The Family Court’s order of May 18, 2026 was set aside and the revision petition disposed of.

Why the judgment matters

Family courts are increasingly shown social media posts that suggest a spouse is comfortably off. This ruling cautions that images of leisure are not evidence of income. A court deciding maintenance must look at proven earnings and disclosed assets, not at how a person chooses to present her life online.

It also applies the settled position that a wife who earns something is not automatically disqualified. Under Section 144 BNSS, which replaces Section 125 CrPC, the question is whether she can maintain herself at the standard she enjoyed in the marriage. Where the husband’s disclosure is incomplete, courts may assess his income from the surrounding material rather than accept his salary slip alone.

Case Title: Wife v. Husband (names withheld) [Crl.Rev.P. No. 374 of 2026; 2026:GAU-AS:16967]
Bench: Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, Gauhati High Court
Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026
Appearances: Advocate D. Pathak for the petitioner-wife; Advocate S. Paul for the respondent-husband

Similar Posts