MCA email service was valid, the Delhi High Court has held: summons and the plaint sent to VLCC Personal Care’s MCA-registered email address counted as proper service in a commercial recovery suit, so the company lost its right to file a written statement. Earlier WhatsApp service was defective, the Court found, but the later email triggered the mandatory 120-day limit, which had expired before VLCC sought recall.

New Delhi: A company must maintain access to the email address it declares in Ministry of Corporate Affairs records and promptly update that record when the address changes, the Delhi High Court has held while dismissing VLCC Personal Care Limited’s challenge to orders striking off its defence in a commercial suit.
Justice Ajay Digpaul delivered the judgment on November 17, 2026 in VLCC Personal Care Limited v. Sudhir Solvent Private Limited. The Court accepted email service on July 23, 2022 as valid and held that the statutory outer limit for filing a written statement had expired before VLCC moved its recall application on November 22, 2022.
The suit is one by Sudhir Solvent for recovery of ₹1,69,32,511.49, plus interest, alleging unpaid amounts for goods supplied. VLCC disputed the claim and alleged defects in the goods. These competing claims were not decided in this judgment, which concerned service of summons and the right to file a written statement.
The email that counted
Following a further direction, the plaintiff’s counsel had sent the plaint and accompanying documents to five email addresses on July 23, 2022, including the address recorded with the MCA as VLCC’s registered email address.
VLCC contended that three addresses were associated with sister concerns and two belonged to employees rather than authorised officers. The High Court found no supporting material establishing that the registered address was inaccessible to the company or that it could not receive communications there.
Paragraph 23 places responsibility on the company to ensure continuous access to the address declared in its MCA record and to make prompt corrections when that address changes. On the evidence before it, the Court rejected the attempt to disown service at that address without having made the necessary changes.
The Court also noted that the plaintiff had used four additional addresses appearing in the memo of parties. In paragraphs 25 and 26, it held that the plaintiff had discharged its burden of communicating the relevant documents and that VLCC was validly served on July 23.
ALSO READ: Karnataka High Court Upholds Belated Plaint Amendment Where No Prejudice Was Shown
Why the WhatsApp service fell short
The commercial court initially treated WhatsApp service on VLCC’s Chief Business Officer on February 16, 2022 as sufficient. On September 1, 2022, it struck off the defence for failure to file a written statement, but did not decree the recovery claim and instead listed the matter for the plaintiff’s evidence.
VLCC argued that the WhatsApp message contained only a photograph of the summons, without the plaint or accompanying documents. It also disputed whether the recipient was a principal officer authorised to receive summons. The company said it discovered an email about the suit in its spam folder in October 2022 and subsequently sought recall of the order.
The High Court held in paragraph 21 that the February 16 service was defective and improper. Order V Rule 2 CPC requires summons to be accompanied by the plaint, and Sudhir Solvent had not produced evidence showing that the plaint accompanied the WhatsApp summons. The trial court had also subsequently directed fresh service.
The 120-day deadline
Applying SCG Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., (2019) 12 SCC 210, the High Court held that the mandatory outer limit under Order VIII CPC followed once valid service was established.
Paragraph 27 records that the 120-day period calculated from July 23 expired on November 20, 2022. VLCC’s recall application was filed on November 22. The Court held that the period could not be extended beyond that statutory limit.
The petition under Article 227 was therefore dismissed, along with pending applications. The ruling leaves VLCC without the right to file a written statement; it does not itself establish that the supplier’s ₹1.69 crore claim is payable.
The decision turns on the complete later service and the company’s registered contact details. It does not dispense with the requirement to provide the plaint, as the Court’s rejection of the earlier WhatsApp service makes clear.
Case Title: VLCC Personal Care Limited v. Sudhir Solvent Private Limited
Case Number: CM(M) 1564/2023
CNR Number: DLHC010378642023
Court and Bench: Delhi High Court; Justice Ajay Digpaul
Decision and Upload Date: November 17, 2026
Outcome: Petition dismissed; July 23, 2022 email service held valid; right to file written statement forfeited after expiry of the commercial-suit deadline.
