Allahabad High Court Seeks BHU Medicine Purchase Enquiry Reports, Says Vice-Chancellor’s Inaction Cannot Be Ignored

4 min read

Banaras Hindu University must place every enquiry committee report on record within ten days, the Allahabad High Court has directed in a PIL over the BHU medicine purchase irregularities, observing that the Vice-Chancellor’s inaction despite multiple reports cannot be ignored at this stage.

Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena of the Allahabad High Court, which sought BHU medicine purchase enquiry reports in a PIL.

Prayagraj: Every procurement record must be preserved by Banaras Hindu University (BHU) until the next hearing, the Allahabad High Court ordered on November 20, 2026, while also calling upon the University to produce all enquiry committee reports on alleged irregularities in the purchase of medicines, surgical items and medical equipment for its hospital [Amit Kumar Mishra & 2 Others v. Union of India & 8 Others].

The order in Criminal Writ-Public Interest Litigation No. 16 of 2026 came from a Division Bench of Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena, which held that the matter prima facie requires consideration.

“Inaction cannot be ignored”

After hearing the parties, the Bench recorded:

“The allegations, if found proved, disclose serious financial irregularities in the purchase of medicines in a public hospital, directly affecting public health. The inaction on the part of the Vice-Chancellor, despite submission of multiple enquiry reports, cannot be ignored at this stage.”

What the Court directed

  • The Vice-Chancellor or Registrar must file a short affidavit placing on record all enquiry committee reports on the alleged medicine purchases, with the action taken report, if any, within ten days.
  • The University must preserve all records of purchase, tender, supply, stock registers, payment vouchers and bills, which shall not be destroyed or tampered with until the next date of hearing.
  • If the reports and affidavit are not filed in time, the Vice-Chancellor or Registrar must remain present before the Court on the next date.
  • The State respondents must file their response.

A copy of the order is to go to the Vice-Chancellor for compliance, through the Registrar (Compliance). The case will be listed as fresh on December 11, 2026. The allegations remain to be tested, and the Court has not ruled on whether an independent probe is warranted.

What the petitioners allege

The petitioners, Amit Kumar Mishra and two others, want an independent investigation into what they describe as large-scale irregularities and embezzlement of public funds in the purchase of medicines, surgical items and medical equipment for the hospital attached to the University, along with action against the officers found responsible.

Several enquiry committees constituted by the University submitted reports in August and September 2026, they say, pointing to gross irregularities, inflated pricing, purchases made without tenders and procurement of substandard items. The petitioners alleged that the Vice-Chancellor took no action, that the reports were not made public and were deliberately suppressed, and that repeated representations to the Vice-Chancellor and the State Government went unanswered. The matter, they argued, involves misuse of public funds meant for poor patients.

Arguments on a CBI or SIT enquiry

Senior Advocate Samir Sharma, assisted by Advocate Himanshu Agrawal, submitted that given the inaction of the University’s highest authorities and the alleged involvement of some senior officers of the University and its Medical College, an enquiry by the University or the State Police would not inspire confidence. He urged the Court to direct an independent agency such as the CBI or a Special Investigation Team to conduct a preliminary enquiry.

Appearing for BHU (respondents 3 to 7), Advocate Pooja Agarwal vehemently opposed the petition.

Why the order matters

Procurement in public hospitals directly shapes the quality of care that poor patients receive. By ordering the University to disclose its own enquiry reports and to freeze the paper trail, the High Court has ensured that the evidence survives while it decides whether the allegations call for an independent investigation, and has put the University’s top administration on notice that inaction will have to be explained.

Case Title: Amit Kumar Mishra & 2 Others v. Union of India & 8 Others [Criminal Writ-Public Interest Litigation No. 16 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena
Date of Order: November 20, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Samir Sharma with Advocate Himanshu Agrawal for the petitioners; Advocate Pooja Agarwal for BHU (respondents 3 to 7); AGA for the State

Similar Posts