Calcutta High Court Rules Car Parking Space Does Not Automatically Pass With Flat Sale Without Conveyance

4 min read

A car parking space does not pass automatically with a flat, the Calcutta High Court has held, turning down a buyer whose conveyance deed is silent on parking and who claimed a space the Housing Board had proposed to allot to his vendors.

Calcutta High Court building, where a flat buyer's claim to a car parking space at Golf Green Urban Complex was rejected.

Kolkata: A flat owner at the Golf Green Urban Complex has failed in his bid for allotment of a car parking space that the West Bengal Housing Board had proposed to allot to the flat’s previous owners, with the Calcutta High Court dismissing his writ petition on November 19, 2026 [Shrawan Kumar Agarwal v. The West Bengal Housing Board & Ors.].

After hearing the matter the same day, Justice Partha Sarathi Sen dismissed WPA 2129 of 2020 together with the connected application, CAN 5 of 2026.

Parking was not an incident of the flat

Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act passes to a transferee all the interest the transferor can pass in the property and its legal incidents, unless a different intention is expressed or necessarily implied. The petitioner, the Court held, had not shown that the parking space was such an incident of the flat, and the schedule to the 1993 conveyance did not mention any parking space.

The Board had agreed to allot the space to the vendors, but the transfer could not be effected. If anyone was aggrieved by that, the Court observed, it was the vendors:

“In the considered view of this Court, in the event, on account of non-transfer of the said car parking space, if anybody is aggrieved, that is the vendors of the writ petitioner, and by no stretch of imagination it can be said that the writ petitioner is aggrieved.”

Its conclusion read:

“…the writ petitioner cannot claim allotment of the aforementioned car parking space, which was proposed to be transferred in the name of the vendors of the writ petitioner, since neither the respondent Housing Board conveyed the said car parking space in favour of the vendors of the writ petitioner, nor does the schedule of the registered deed of conveyance as executed in favour of the writ petitioner make any whisper regarding the automatic transfer of car parking space along with the transfer of Apartment No. 3A.”

The memos and the earlier sale

The petitioner, Shrawan Kumar Agarwal, had challenged a Housing Board memo dated September 19, 2019, which revoked the Board’s earlier memo of October 29, 1997 on allotment of a car parking space in the complex.

Apartment No. 3A was jointly owned by Jayanta Kumar Basu and Anita Basu. They applied to the Board for a car parking space in November 1992 and deposited Rs 7,000, and a provisional allotment letter for space BG-3 followed on December 18, 1992. On October 29, 1997, the Board decided to allot space BG-9 in the name of Jayanta Kumar Basu and said it would execute a deed of conveyance in due course.

The flat, however, had already changed hands. The Basus sold it to the petitioner by a registered deed of conveyance dated March 30, 1993, and in a separate letter of the same date assured him that they would hand over the parking space once the Board allotted it to them.

What each side said

Senior Advocate Arindam Banerjee, for the petitioner, relied on Section 8 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, to argue that the parking allotment passed to the petitioner along with the flat. Having bought the apartment, he said, the petitioner stepped into the shoes of the earlier owners and was willing to pay the consideration, stamp duty and registration charges.

For the Housing Board, the answer was that the registered deed transferring the flat made no reference to any car parking space, so the petitioner could not claim an allotment merely because he had bought the apartment.

Finding no merit in the petition, the Court dismissed it along with the connected application, vacated the earlier interim order and made no order as to costs.

Why the judgment matters

Parking disputes are common in housing complexes, especially older Housing Board projects where parking was allotted separately. The ruling is a reminder to flat buyers that a parking space passes with a flat only if the conveyance deed provides for it; a side letter from the seller does not give the buyer a claim against the allotting authority.

Case Title: Shrawan Kumar Agarwal v. The West Bengal Housing Board & Ors. [WPA 2129 of 2020 with I.A. No. CAN 5 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Partha Sarathi Sen
Date of Judgment: November 19, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Arindam Banerjee with Advocates Sulagna Mukherjee and Rohit Chowdhury for the petitioner; Advocates Tapan Coomar Dey and Shreya Chatterjee for the West Bengal Housing Board

Similar Posts