Allahabad High Court Imposes Rs 25,000 Costs On UP Government For Decade-Long Chargesheet Delay, Flags Police Lethargy

4 min read

“A litigant who knocks on the doors of the justice delivery system cannot be made to suffer indefinitely on account of bureaucratic lethargy and sheer indifference of the police authorities,” the Allahabad High Court has said, ordering the UP Government to pay Rs 25,000 to a complainant over a decade-long chargesheet delay.

Allahabad High Court, whose Lucknow Bench imposed costs on the UP Government over a decade-long chargesheet delay.

Lucknow: After Pratapgarh Police failed for over ten years to file a chargesheet in a 2015 FIR, the Allahabad High Court at Lucknow has imposed an exemplary token cost of Rs 25,000 on the Uttar Pradesh Government, leaving it open to the State to recover the amount from the police officials responsible [Chandbabu v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Revenue Lko. and 2 Others].

A Division Bench of Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava disposed of the criminal writ petition on November 16, 2026, calling the handling of the case an alarming state of affairs that showed gross dereliction of duty.

A Bench not persuaded by the apology

By the time the Court passed its final order on November 16, it had been told that the trial court took cognizance on October 14, 2026. In reply to the show-cause notice on costs, the SP tendered an unconditional apology and said the delay occurred because staff had misplaced the case diary and papers. The Bench was not satisfied.

“The charge-sheet, which had purportedly been prepared years ago, was finally submitted before the court concerned only on 06.10.2026. It is therefore apparent that the entire machinery went into motion only under the compelling gaze of this Court.”

“A litigant who knocks on the doors of the justice delivery system cannot be made to suffer indefinitely on account of bureaucratic lethargy and sheer indifference of the police authorities. The manner in which the matter has been handled indicates gross dereliction of duty.”

Senior police officials are expected to actively supervise investigations and monitor criminal proceedings in their jurisdiction, the Bench said, rather than waking up only when the Court issues notices and orders. It described the response to its show-cause notice as a casual explanation.

Rs 25,000, and who may have to bear it

Holding that the petitioner was entitled to be compensated for a delay of more than ten years, the Court imposed an exemplary token cost of Rs 25,000, payable to him by the State Government within four weeks of receipt of a certified copy of the order. It left it open to the State to recover the amount from the erring police officials found responsible for the “egregious delay and dereliction of duty”. The writ petition was disposed of.

How the delay came to light

The petitioner, Chandbabu, was the informant in an FIR lodged in March 2015 at Police Station Mandhata, District Pratapgarh, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 323, 452, 504 and 506 IPC. He moved the High Court seeking a direction to the Superintendent of Police, Pratapgarh, to act on his September 11, 2026 application and to ensure that the chargesheet was filed, since the investigation had not been concluded more than a decade later.

At the hearing on September 28, the Additional Government Advocate told the Court that a chargesheet had first been forwarded on April 24, 2015, but objections were raised. After further investigation it was forwarded again on June 10, 2023, but the case diary was later misplaced. An inquiry into this began only on September 25, 2026, three days after a copy of the writ petition was served on the Government Advocate.

“It is very surprising that in an FIR of the year 2015, till date, the police report has not been filed and the Station House Officer concerned is also sleeping over the matter and has not taken any action.”

The Court directed the SP, Pratapgarh, to inquire personally and file an affidavit. On October 14, it was told that the misplaced chargesheet had been traced and filed before the trial court on October 6, 2026, and that a show-cause notice had been issued on October 9 to Head Constable Vishnu Kant Singh over alleged dereliction of duty. The Court then asked the SP to explain why exemplary costs should not be imposed.

Why the order matters

A timely police report is the step that moves a criminal case from investigation to trial. When it is not filed, the complainant is left without any forum to pursue the case, however long the delay. The order treats that prolonged inaction as a wrong in itself and compensates the complainant, rather than closing the matter once the chargesheet was finally filed.

By allowing the State to recover the costs from the officials found responsible, the Court ties the cost of delay to individual accountability. The ruling also adds to a series of Allahabad High Court orders calling on senior police officers in Uttar Pradesh to supervise pending investigations, instead of acting only once a writ petition is served.

Case Title: Chandbabu v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Revenue Lko. and 2 Others [Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 9613 of 2026; 2026:AHC-LKO:81938-DB]
Bench: Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava, Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench)
Date of Order: November 16, 2026
Appearances: Jaikaran and Shravan Kumar Yadav for the petitioner; Government Advocate for the State

Similar Posts