Should injuries and killings caused by synthetic kite string be handled as petty offences? The Punjab and Haryana High Court has asked the Punjab Government to take a fresh look at Chinese Manjha Deaths, and at the compensation victims should receive.

Chandigarh: Directing the Punjab Government to take a fresh relook at the problem of “Chinese String”, the synthetic kite string blamed for injuries and deaths across the State, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has asked it to examine whether such cases should continue to be treated like petty offences and to decide the compensation payable to victims [Public Interest Litigation on ‘Chinese String’ v. State of Punjab & Ors.].
The order was passed by a Division Bench of Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor, who listed the matter on January 27, 2027. By then the concerned Secretary of the State must file a fresh affidavit.
Petty offences, the petitioners say
The petitioners argued that the FIRs registered over the use of “Chinese String” at best allege petty offences. In their submission, the public is therefore not taking the matter seriously and there is no effective check on its use, and the more than 400 FIRs registered themselves show the scale of the problem.
What the State had already done
Following directions in an earlier public interest litigation (CWP-PIL-2-2025), the State passed an order on September 20, 2025, the Court noted. That order declared the making of “Chinese String” illegal because it causes injuries and deaths, and suggested measures to curb its use. The State also set up a committee to look into compensation for victims.
In its affidavit, the State said more than 400 FIRs had been registered in connection with “Chinese String”. State counsel told the Court that a three-member committee had already submitted its report on compensation.
The Bench asks for a fresh look
The Bench took note of the existing policy decision but found that the record called for a fresh look:
“Though, we find that the concerned Additional Chief Secretary has already taken a policy decision on 20.09.2025 but taking into consideration the facts as have been placed on record, we deem it appropriate to direct the State Government to have a fresh relook at the issue considering the large number of such instances in the State causing injuries to individuals and loss of human lives.”
On the nature of the offences and the quantum of compensation, the Court left the first call to the State:
“Whether such instances are to be treated like any other petty offences or some strict view needs to be taken, can be examined at the level of the State at the first instance. What kind of compensation ought to be awarded to such victims would also require careful consideration at the level of the State Government.”
The concerned Secretary of the State of Punjab has been asked to examine the issue in light of these observations and to set out the State’s stand on affidavit before the next hearing.
Deterrence and compensation now before the State
The petitioners say the string is still in use despite the State’s 2025 order and more than 400 FIRs, because the offences registered are petty. By asking whether these incidents should still be handled as petty offences, the Court has put the question of deterrence squarely before the State: if the penal response is too light, the ban is unlikely to change behaviour.
Victims are also in focus. With a committee report on compensation already submitted, the State will now have to state on affidavit how those injured, and the families of those killed, are to be compensated.
Case Title: Public Interest Litigation on ‘Chinese String’ v. State of Punjab & Ors.
Bench: Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor, Punjab and Haryana High Court
Next Date of Hearing: January 27, 2027
