Allahabad High Court Directs UP To Curb Private Practice By Government Doctors, Rejects NHM Objection

4 min read

“The argument has been made only to be rejected,” the Allahabad High Court said, turning down the National Health Mission’s objection to a PIL on Private Practice By Government Doctors, and ordering an inquiry into a death in police custody at a Balrampur health centre.

Allahabad High Court building, where the Lucknow Bench directed enforcement of rules barring private practice by government doctors.

Lucknow: The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court has directed the Director General, Medical Health and Family Welfare, Uttar Pradesh, to take all appropriate steps to prevent government doctors from practising privately in violation of the Uttar Pradesh Government Doctors (Allopathic) Restriction on Private Practice Rules, 1983. It has also rejected the National Health Mission’s objection that a public interest litigation on the issue was not maintainable [Ankur Mishr v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Medical Health and Family Welfare Lko. and 4 Others].

A Division Bench of Justice Rajan Roy and Justice Manjive Shukla passed the order on November 5, 2026 in the PIL filed by Ankur Mishr, and listed the matter on December 21, 2026.

“Made only to be rejected”

Appearing for the National Health Mission, Puneet Chandra argued that the reliefs sought related to the service conditions of doctors, so a PIL would not lie. The Bench dismissed the argument in sharp terms:

“The argument has been made only to be rejected. Probably the subject matter and purport of the writ petition has not been appropriately understood. If there are rules pertaining to government doctors prohibiting private practice and on account of indulgence of such government doctors in private practice, the larger public interest is affected then certainly a PIL would be maintainable.”

Rather than raise a technical objection which “in any case is unfounded in law”, the Court said, the National Health Mission should first have asked itself “whether the malpractice exists and if so, who is responsible for curing it”. The State, the Court recorded, fairly did not oppose the PIL on that ground.

What the petition alleges

The petition alleges large-scale private practice by government doctors in breach of the 1983 Rules. A supplementary affidavit taken on record on the day of the hearing refers to Ranjeet Saini, a resident of Balrampur district, whose health allegedly deteriorated while he was in police custody.

As the affidavit has it, he was allegedly locked in a room at the government hospital instead of being given immediate medical treatment, received no attention despite repeated cries for help, and died within a few hours. The petitioner says two police personnel were suspended over the incident but that, to his knowledge, the health department has neither acted against its own staff nor held any inquiry.

Rule 3, and an inquiry at Tulsipur

For the State, Additional Chief Standing Counsel Badrish Tripathi told the Court that disciplinary proceedings were started against some doctors in 2025 and that some were suspended. The Bench asked for the outcome to be placed on record, and said enforcement of the Rules cannot be a one-off reaction to an incident:

“Moreover, this has to be a continuing exercise to monitor implementation of Rule 3 of the Rules, 1983 and not as one of incident. Let such an exercise be conducted by opposite party no.2 in District-Balrampur.”

On the death in custody, the Court directed a specific inquiry into the allegation that the patient was locked in at the Community Health Centre, Tulsipur, Balrampur, and died because no doctor was available there. A report is to be filed by the next date. The inquiry, the Court clarified, is a fact-finding exercise, and if illegalities are found, further action would have to be referred to the competent authority.

The allegations about the death remain to be examined in that inquiry, and the Court has recorded no finding on them.

Why the order matters

The order makes clear that a rule governing the conduct of public servants can be enforced through a PIL when its breach hurts the public they serve. Doctors’ service conditions are ordinarily a matter between employer and employee, but absent doctors at a government health centre are a public health problem, and the Court treated it as one.

By asking for continuous monitoring of Rule 3 in Balrampur rather than a single round of action, and by ordering a fact-finding inquiry into a death in custody at a health centre, the Bench has tied the abstract rule to its human cost. The next hearing will show whether the health department’s inquiry and the disciplinary record match the allegations.

Case Title: Ankur Mishr v. State of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Medical Health and Family Welfare Lko. and 4 Others
Case No.: Public Interest Litigation (PIL) No. 1003 of 2026
Bench: Justice Rajan Roy and Justice Manjive Shukla, Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench)
Date of Order: November 5, 2026
Appearances: Prashant Tiwari for the petitioner; Badrish Tripathi, Additional CSC, for the State; Puneet Chandra for the National Health Mission

Similar Posts