Does time on the Bench count towards the District Judge Post? The Supreme Court says it does: seven years of combined experience as an advocate and as a judicial officer is enough, and it has directed the Madhya Pradesh High Court to continue Rahul Singh in service.

New Delhi: A person in judicial service who has seven years or more of combined experience as an advocate and as a judicial officer is eligible for appointment as a District Judge or Additional District Judge under Article 233 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court has held, allowing the writ petition of a Madhya Pradesh judicial officer who was refused appointment in 2018 for want of seven years of continuous practice at the Bar [Rahul Singh v. Hon’ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh & Anr.].
Justice MM Sundresh and Justice Prasanna B Varale passed the order on October 13, 2026. It makes absolute an interim order of April 22, 2019, under which the petitioner has been working as an Additional District and Sessions Judge.
A question already settled
The Bench began from the position that whether judicial service can be counted towards the seven-year requirement was no longer open. The Constitution Bench had decided it in Rejanish K.V. v. K. Deepa, and the Bench recorded that ruling in these words:
“A person who has been or who is in judicial service and has a combined experience of seven years or more as an advocate or a judicial officer would be eligible for being considered and appointed as a District Judge/Additional District Judge under Article 233 of the Constitution.”
That judgment also set 35 years as the minimum age for advocates and judicial officers alike, counted on the date of application, so that both groups compete on a level field. It further held that the line of decisions running from Satya Narain Singh v. High Court of Allahabad (1985) to Dheeraj Mor v. High Court of Delhi (2020) did not lay down the correct law.
The petitioner and the 2018 memos
Rahul Singh came to the Supreme Court under Article 32. He had sat the Madhya Pradesh Higher Judiciary Service (Entry Level) (Direct Recruitment from Bar) Examination, 2017, and asked for a direction to the High Court to appoint him as an Additional District and Sessions Judge on that selection, with seniority and consequential benefits.
Two High Court communications stood in his way: Memo No. 322 dated January 31, 2018 and Memo No. 385 dated May 21, 2018. Both denied him appointment on the ground that he did not have seven years of continuous practice as an advocate on April 13, 2017, the last date for applications, and he challenged them in the petition.
The Court noted that he had cleared all three stages of the selection. It also recorded that he had about ten years and one month of practice at the Bar and about one year and three months of service as a judicial officer.
The direction
Applying the Constitution Bench’s position, the Bench noted that the petitioner had been working as an Additional District and Sessions Judge since April 2019 and that his selection on merit was not in dispute. It held:
“In such view of the matter, the interim order passed by this Court, vide order dated 22.04.2019, is made absolute, and the Writ Petition stands allowed, by directing the respondent(s) to continue the service of the writ petitioner.”
All benefits to which he is otherwise entitled under his original selection shall also be granted to him, the Court added.
A selection frozen since 2018
For decades, judicial officers who had once practised at the Bar were kept out of the direct recruitment quota for district judges, on the reading that Article 233(2) required a candidate to be a practising advocate on the date of application. The Constitution Bench changed that by counting time on the Bench along with time at the Bar, subject to a common minimum age.
This order shows that ruling reaching a selection stalled in 2018. A candidate who cleared every stage on merit but was refused appointment on the older view now has his appointment secured, along with the benefits tied to his original selection.
Case Title: Rahul Singh v. Hon’ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh & Anr.
Case No.: Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1049 of 2018
Bench: Justice MM Sundresh and Justice Prasanna B Varale, Supreme Court of India
Date of Order: October 13, 2026
