Rajasthan High Court Flags 70-Fold Circle Rate Gap, Orders Suo Motu Case After Revenue Inaction

4 min read

Finding a circle rate gap of nearly 70 times between the official District Level Committee rate and the real market value of land in Jalore, the Rajasthan High Court has directed registration of a suo motu petition, noting that the Revenue Department took no action on its earlier order.

Rajasthan High Court building, where Justice Baljinder Singh Sandhu ordered a suo motu case on the circle rate gap in Jalore.

Jodhpur: The Rajasthan High Court has directed its registry to register a suo motu petition on the huge disparity between District Level Committee (DLC) rates and the actual market value of immovable property in Jalore, and to place it before the Chief Justice for listing before an appropriate Bench, while disposing of a batch of bail applications [Vishal Singh v. State of Rajasthan and connected matters].

The order dated October 28, 2026 was passed by Justice Baljinder Singh Sandhu at the Jodhpur principal seat.

Land worth Rs 5.51 crore registered at Rs 8 lakh

The issue first surfaced while the Court was hearing connected bail applications earlier this year. In an order dated May 21, 2026, it recorded that the Investigating Officer had drawn its attention to an agreement between the parties, forming part of the case diary, which put the value of the land at Rs 5,51,00,000. The sale deed, however, was executed for only Rs 8,00,000.

The purchaser’s counsel and the Investigating Officer told the Court that this happened because the DLC rate for the land was only Rs 8 lakh, so the document was registered at that figure. The Court said in May that this appeared to amount to “a massive fraud upon the State exchequer”, and that it prima facie showed transfer of unaccounted cash in property deals in the area. It sent the matter to the Principal Secretary, Revenue Department, for appropriate action and remedial measures, and called for an inquiry report.

Why DLC rates matter

Explaining that DLC rates are the circle rates which fix the minimum value for registering sale deeds and on which stamp duty is levied, the Court observed:

“Although some variation between the DLC rates and the actual market value may be inevitable, an exorbitant disparity between the two may facilitate the circulation of unaccounted money and cash transactions representing the difference between the actual market value and the value declared in the registered instrument.”

It added that fixing appropriate DLC rates is “essential to discourage the undervaluation of property, the use of unaccounted money in property transactions and the consequent evasion of stamp duty.”

No action by the Revenue Department

The Court recorded that although a copy of its May order had been forwarded to the Principal Secretary, Revenue, for immediate action, “no further action appears to have been taken in the matter.”

Matter sent to the Chief Justice

Justice Sandhu said it would not be appropriate to examine State revenue and the fixing of DLC rates while deciding bail pleas, but held that the issue involved “a matter of wider public interest” that merited consideration by a Division Bench. The Court directed the office to register a suo motu petition and place it before the Chief Justice for consideration and listing before the appropriate Bench. The bail applications were disposed of accordingly.

Why the order matters

Circle rates that lag far behind real prices let buyers and sellers register deeds at a fraction of the true price, cutting the State’s stamp duty and leaving room for cash payments off the books. By moving the issue from a bail file to a suo motu case before the Chief Justice, the High Court has opened the door to a wider review of how DLC rates are fixed and revised in Rajasthan, and to accountability for the Revenue Department’s silence on its earlier order.

Case Title: Vishal Singh v. State of Rajasthan, with Gautam Chand v. State of Rajasthan and Daulat Ram v. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous Bail Application No. 5660/2026 and connected matters)
Neutral Citation: 2026:RJ-JD:52920
Bench: Justice Baljinder Singh Sandhu, Rajasthan High Court (Jodhpur)
Date of Order: October 28, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Devki Nandan Vyas for the petitioner(s); Public Prosecutor Hanuman Prajapati with Om Prakash for the State

Similar Posts