Punjab And Haryana HC Issues Contempt Notice To Chief Secretary Over Alleged Misstatement On DA Appeal

4 min read

The Punjab and Haryana HC contempt notice to the Chief Secretary follows the Bench’s prima facie observation of “a deliberate misstatement of fact” over whether the State’s Supreme Court appeal on dearness allowance had been re-filed after curing defects. No finding of contempt has been recorded.

Punjab and Haryana High Court building in Chandigarh, which issued a contempt notice to the Chief Secretary over an alleged misstatement on the DA appeal

Chandigarh: On Tuesday, the Punjab and Haryana High Court asked Punjab Chief Secretary KP Sinha, by notice, why criminal contempt proceedings should not be initiated against him for allegedly misleading the Court about the filing of the State’s appeal before the Supreme Court against the High Court’s dearness allowance (DA) judgment [proceedings on applications under Article 215 for compliance with the 3 August 2026 judgment].

The Division Bench of Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor adjourned the matter to Friday and directed the Chief Secretary to remain present. The observations are prima facie only, and no finding of contempt has been recorded against anyone.

The Registry report and the Bench’s reaction

On Tuesday, the Court had called for a report from the Supreme Court Registry on the status of the SLP. According to the Bench, the report showed that the Registry’s defects had not been removed, which stood in contrast to the statement made on Monday. The Bench also did not accept the Advocate General’s position that the SLP had no defects, and recorded that even the re-filed appeal contained numerous defects.

We prima facie find that there is a deliberate misstatement of fact made by the Chief Secretary before the Court.

The Bench observed that the intended message of telling it the appeal had been re-filed was that the defects had been cured. Re-filing a defective appeal almost a month after it was first filed, it said, prima facie indicated an attempt to misrepresent facts. The Court added that it had been adjourning the matter repeatedly to accommodate the State, and that the Chief Secretary had been summoned only after the defects remained uncured despite repeated opportunities.

How the matter reached this point

The High Court’s judgment of 3 August directed the State to release all pending instalments of dearness allowance and dearness relief to its employees and pensioners at the rates paid to All India Services officers serving in Punjab. It also restrained the government from unproductive expenditure, such as large-scale advertising, until the dues are paid.

The State took the judgment to the Supreme Court, but the appeal has been with the Supreme Court Registry since 1 September because of defects. The High Court had earlier summoned the Chief Secretary for Monday and Tuesday, and on Monday it was told that the SLP had been re-filed after the defects were removed.

Objections from the State, reply from the applicants

Senior Advocate Vikas Singh, who also appeared for the Punjab government, contended that the Court could not hear applications in an appeal that had already been disposed of, particularly when a contempt petition over the same non-compliance was pending before a single judge. He alleged bench-hunting by the applicants and submitted that the Court was being used by politically motivated applicants with Assembly elections approaching.

The Chief Justice cautioned counsel to be careful about what he said, and the Court stated that it would not enter political aspects. It said that filing an SLP takes time, perhaps a few days or a week, but not an indefinite period. The Bench described what was happening in the matter as unusual and strange, and said it did not approve of it.

For the applicants, Senior Advocate Sanjay Kaushal argued that the Court had not become functus officio because, while disposing of the case, it had directed a compliance filing. He added that the applicants were the original petitioners or intervenors.

Friday’s hearing

The Court recorded that it had held back from passing any order on the applications once the State said it had filed an SLP, and that it was now compelled to act because the defects remained. Mr Singh sought time for the Chief Secretary to appear physically, and the matter was adjourned to Friday. The notice is a show cause notice only, and the Chief Secretary has the opportunity to explain.

Case Title: Proceedings on applications under Article 215 for compliance with the High Court’s 3 August 2026 judgment on dearness allowance and dearness relief (case number not reported)
Bench: Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor, Punjab and Haryana High Court
Date of Order: 6 October 2026
Next Hearing: Friday, 9 October 2026

Appearances: Senior Advocate Vikas Singh and Advocate General Maninderjit Singh Bedi for the State of Punjab; Senior Advocate Sanjay Kaushal for the applicants.

Similar Posts