The Orissa High Court has held that a Children’s Court cannot simply act on a Juvenile Justice Board’s recommendation to try a child as an adult, and must decide that question for itself before an adult trial can begin.

Cuttack: The Orissa High Court has set aside the conviction of a man who was about 17 years old when he was accused of sexual offences against a minor girl, holding that the Children’s Court at Angul tried him as an adult without first making its own assessment under Section 19(1) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, and acquitted him of the charges [PS v. State of Odisha].
A single-judge Bench of Justice Sibo Sankar Mishra allowed the criminal appeal, holding that the failure to undertake the statutory exercise went to the legality of the adult trial itself and was not a curable irregularity.
Background
According to the prosecution, an FIR was lodged on February 5, 2016, alleging that the appellant had committed repeated sexual offences against the minor victim over a period of about a year. He was charged under Sections 450, 376(2)(i) and 376(2)(n) of the Indian Penal Code, read with Section 6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012.
As the appellant was about 17 years old at the time of the alleged offence, the matter went before the Juvenile Justice Board, which on November 8, 2016, directed that he could be tried as an adult. The Additional District and Sessions Judge-cum-Special Court under the POCSO Act, Angul, then tried him and, by judgment dated March 5, 2020, convicted him. He was sentenced to 15 years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 20,000 under Section 6 of the POCSO Act, and to five years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 5,000 under Section 450 IPC. He challenged the conviction before the High Court.
The Board’s preliminary assessment
Examining the record, Justice Mishra found that the Board had “mechanically accepted the opinions of the psychologist, counsellor and medical officer without independently evaluating” the statutory parameters, and that “no Social Investigation Report or Social Background Report was obtained.” The Court also noted that the Board had proceeded without independently determining the appellant’s age.
A two-tier safeguard
Reading Sections 15, 18(3) and 19 of the 2015 Act together, the High Court held that the Board‘s recommendation is only the first step. It observed:
“The legislative scheme does not contemplate an automatic conversion of the Board’s recommendation into an adult criminal trial.”
Explaining the role of the Children’s Court once a case is transferred to it, the Court said:
“The Children’s Court, on its own, upon a matter being referred to under Section 18(3), would still examine whether the child is to be tried as an adult or not.”
On the nature of the discretion under Section 19(1), it held:
“The discretion contemplated by the provision is as to the course to be adopted after the Children’s Court applies its mind to the question whether the child needs to be tried as an adult.”
Not a curable irregularity
Finding that the Children’s Court at Angul had proceeded straight to an adult trial on the strength of the Board‘s order, the High Court held that the defect went to jurisdiction:
“The Children’s Court, therefore, did not merely commit an error while conducting an otherwise valid trial; it failed to undertake the statutory exercise which was a condition precedent to its assuming jurisdiction.”
It added that “the failure to comply with Section 19 is fundamental and strikes at the legality of the adult trial itself.”
The Court referred to the Supreme Court‘s decisions in Barun Chandra Thakur v. Master Bholu (2023) 12 SCC 401, Ajeet Gurjar v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2023), Sri Ganesh v. State of T.N. (2017) 3 SCC 280, X v. State of Bihar (2026) and Dinesh Kumar v. State of Haryana (2026).
The outcome
Setting aside the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated March 5, 2020, the High Court ordered:
“The appellant is accordingly acquitted of the charges.”
The acquittal rests on the failure to follow the procedure mandated by the Juvenile Justice Act before an adult trial, rather than on a fresh assessment of the evidence.
Why The Orissa High Court Judgment Matters
The 2015 Act allows a child aged 16 to 18 accused of a heinous offence to be tried as an adult, but only after two separate checks: a preliminary assessment by the Juvenile Justice Board under Section 15, and an independent decision by the Children’s Court under Section 19(1). The ruling makes clear that the second check is not a formality, and that a Children’s Court which treats the Board’s order as final acts without jurisdiction.
The judgment also signals that a procedural failure at this threshold cannot be cured at the appellate stage. Where the statutory safeguards for children in conflict with the law are skipped, the resulting adult trial and conviction cannot stand, however serious the allegations.
Case Title: PS v. State of Odisha [CRLA No. 286 of 2020]
Bench: Justice Sibo Sankar Mishra, Orissa High Court
Date of Judgment: September 30, 2026
Appearances: Debidutta Mohapatra, Advocate, for the appellant; Samvit Mohanty, Amicus Curiae; Ashok Kumar Apat, Additional Government Advocate, for the State
If you know of a child in need of care and protection, call CHILDLINE at 1098.
