Kerala High Court: Trial Judge Cannot Gather Evidence During Local Inspection Under Section 347 BNSS

4 min read

Can a trial judge use a local inspection to settle a fact the prosecution never proved? The Kerala High Court has said no: a local inspection under Section 347 BNSS cannot be used to gather evidence, and a Special Judge’s note on a disputed fact in an NDPS case has been struck down.

Kerala High Court building in Kochi, where Justice PV Balakrishnan ruled on local inspection under Section 347 BNSS in an NDPS case.

Kochi: A trial judge carrying out a local inspection under Section 347 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) cannot treat it as a substitute for evidence, and cannot go about collecting additional information or evidence during it, the Kerala High Court has ruled. The Court declared illegal an observation that a Special Judge had recorded in the memorandum of inspection on a disputed question of fact [Petitioner (accused) v. State of Kerala; case title to be verified].

The verdict came from Justice PV Balakrishnan, on a petition by one of the accused in an NDPS case.

Where the line falls

Examining Section 347 BNSS, the Court relied on State of Kerala v. Chandran [1973 KHC 144] and the Supreme Court’s decisions in Pritam Singh v. State of Punjab and Keisam Kumar Singh v. State of Manipur. Those rulings hold that a local inspection must not take the place of evidence, because what a judge sees on the spot cannot be tested by cross-examination.

11.1 kg ganja beneath a car seat

The petitioner faces charges under Sections 20(b)(ii)(B), 25 and 29 of the NDPS Act. According to the prosecution, he and the first accused were found in possession of, and transporting, 11.1 kg of dried ganja kept in a plastic sack beneath the front passenger seat of a Maruti Alto car.

The defence told the trial court that there is not enough space beneath the seat to conceal the contraband. Since the prosecution had led no evidence on the storage space, the petitioner applied under Section 347 BNSS for a local inspection of the vehicle.

The memorandum of inspection

The Special Judge’s memorandum recorded that there was sufficient space beneath the seat to conceal the contraband. The petitioner contended that it did not record the facts for which the inspection had been ordered, and asked for a detailed memorandum with the measurements of the space. The trial court dismissed that request, which brought him to the High Court.

Before the High Court, he argued that he was prejudiced because he had no chance to cross-examine on what the memorandum recorded, and that he had sought the inspection only because the prosecution had led no evidence on the point. The prosecution countered that, having himself asked for details about the space, he could not now challenge the memorandum.

The High Court found that the trial court had ventured to gather additional information and evidence during the inspection, and held:

“The observation thus made by the learned Special Judge…is clearly on the disputed question of fact raised in the case i.e., whether the contraband allegedly seized by the prosecution can be kept beneath the passenger seat of the vehicle. If so, I have no hesitation to find that the said observation in…Memorandum is illegal.”

The petitioner’s own application fared no better, for the same reason:

“…application filed by the petitioner seeking the learned Special Judge to record the dimensions of the space beneath the seat and include it in the Memorandum also has no legs to stand, since it amounts to collection of evidence, which is impermissible.”

Accordingly, the order rejecting the request for a detailed memorandum was left undisturbed and the petition was dismissed.

The NDPS case is pending trial. The prosecution allegations are untested, the High Court expressed no view on the merits, and the accused are entitled to the presumption of innocence.

Why the judgment matters

For trial courts working under the new criminal procedure code, the ruling marks the limit of Section 347 BNSS. A local inspection helps a judge understand evidence already on record. It is not a way for the judge or a party to fill gaps on a disputed fact, since what the judge observes cannot be tested through cross-examination.

Case Title: Petitioner (accused) v. State of Kerala (title and case number to be verified)
Bench: Justice PV Balakrishnan, Kerala High Court
Date of Judgment: To be verified (reported November 17, 2026)
Appearances: S. Rajeev and others for the petitioner; Public Prosecutor Devadas H. Mallan for the State

Similar Posts