Social media handle not licence to post any message one wants, the Karnataka High Court has held, refusing to quash two FIRs over an alleged online campaign of defamatory and threatening posts against a young man in Belthangady.

Bengaluru: Dismissing two criminal petitions against FIRs registered by the Belthangady police over social media posts allegedly targeting a young man from Ujire, the Karnataka High Court has held that the availability of a social media handle does not give anyone a free licence to post whatever they want, and has directed the police to complete the investigation at the earliest [Shubha v. State of Karnataka and Another].
Justice Suraj Govindaraj passed both oral orders on October 15, 2026, in Criminal Petition No. 7143 of 2025 filed by Shubha, and Criminal Petition No. 7136 of 2025 filed by Shubha and Mohan. Both petitions were filed under Section 482 CrPC read with Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
Where the Court drew the line
In Shubha’s individual petition, the Court held that free speech online has limits:
“A social media handle being available would not give a free license to any person to post any message that a person wants. The messages which are posted ought to be within the exercise and limits of Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.”
It added that the manner in which the messages were posted, including the hospital-bed photograph, indicated at this stage that the complainant’s allegations were not false, and that whether and to what extent they were true would require investigation. The Court noted that an earlier interim order had held up the investigation.
The complaints behind the petitions
Both cases arise from complaints lodged on April 24, 2025 by Thanush M. Shetty, a 24-year-old resident of Ujire in Belthangady taluk, Dakshina Kannada. Crime No. 27/2025 was registered against Shubha under Section 353(2) (statements promoting enmity between groups) and Section 62 (attempt to commit an offence) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). Crime No. 26/2025 was registered against Shubha and Mohan under Section 353(2) of the BNS. Both cases are pending before the Principal Civil Judge and JMFC Court, Belthangady.
In the first complaint, the complainant alleged that on April 16, 2024, at around 6 pm, an attempt was made to run him over with an autorickshaw at Shubha’s instance, and that she had been posting messages on social media defaming him. The State told the Court that a photograph of the complainant lying in a hospital bed had been posted on Instagram with an inappropriate message, and that other messages posted on an Instagram handle carried threats against him.
The second complaint alleged an online campaign run through multiple social media accounts, including the circulation of fabricated news reports, morphed photographs and false claims linking the complainant to serious criminal acts. It also alleged that he was falsely portrayed as belonging to a particular religious community so as to provoke hostility against him. The complainant sought investigation into the campaign and the persons behind the accounts.
These remain allegations. They are yet to be tested in investigation and trial, the High Court has expressed no view on whether they are true, and the petitioners are entitled to the presumption of innocence.
The petitioners’ case
In the first petition, counsel for Shubha submitted that no such incident had taken place and that the autorickshaw driver had not even been made an accused. The High Court Government Pleader responded that a separate FIR had been registered against the driver and a charge sheet filed in that matter, and that serious allegations had been made against the petitioner in the present case.
In the second petition, the petitioners argued that the allegations arose out of the dispute surrounding the Soujanya murder case, in which two groups had emerged and had been posting messages against each other on social media. They contended that the complaint was lodged out of vengeance because they support the Dharmasthala temple, and that they could not be prosecuted merely for expressing their views or taking part in an exchange of messages online.
The second petition: a feud is no shield
Here the Court framed the question as whether the complaint, taken at face value, disclosed the ingredients of Section 353(2) of the BNS. It found that the allegations went beyond an exchange of opinions between two groups, and rejected the argument that a running online feud offered any cover:
“The existence of a dispute between groups does not confer immunity from criminal liability where the statements or material circulated are alleged to satisfy the ingredients of an offence. Each act of publication or circulation must be examined on its own facts and in the light of the applicable statutory requirements.”
On the vengeance plea, the Court said the claim that the petitioners support the Dharmasthala temple and were targeted for it “is a matter of defence” and cannot by itself justify quashing an FIR that contains specific allegations. Who operated the accounts, whether the posts were false, and whether the intent required by Section 353(2) existed were, it said, factual matters for investigation, including examination of the social media accounts and digital records.
“The allegations in the complaint, taken at face value, disclose a case requiring investigation into the alleged circulation of false and inflammatory material through social media. The petitioners have not established that the FIR is liable to be quashed at this stage.”
What the police must now do
Both petitions were dismissed. In Crime No. 27/2025, the Belthangady police were directed to carry out the necessary investigation at the earliest and file a report. In Crime No. 26/2025, the police were directed to investigate the allegations and counter-allegations and submit a final report at the earliest.
Why the order matters
The orders restate a settled limit on quashing jurisdiction: where a complaint, read as it stands, discloses the ingredients of an offence, a High Court will not cut short the investigation by weighing defences such as motive or vengeance. Questions of who ran an account and whether a post was false are left to investigation and trial.
They also add to a growing body of rulings on online speech. The Court treated Article 19(1)(a) as the outer limit of what may be posted, and made clear that being part of a two-sided social media fight over a contested public controversy does not take an individual post outside criminal law if it otherwise meets the statutory test. At the same time, by directing a probe into both allegations and counter-allegations, the Court left the merits entirely open.
Case Title: Shubha v. State of Karnataka and Another [Criminal Petition No. 7143 of 2025, 2026:KHC:58487]; Shubha and Another v. State of Karnataka and Another [Criminal Petition No. 7136 of 2025, 2026:KHC:58488]
Bench: Justice Suraj Govindaraj, High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru
Date of Order: October 15, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Kethan Kumar for the petitioners; HCGP Ranjith Kumar N. for the State; respondent No. 2 served
