Quashing a matrimonial cruelty case against a husband who was away pursuing his PhD when the alleged acts took place, the Calcutta High Court has held that not answering wife’s calls is not cruelty under Section 498A IPC.

Kolkata: The Calcutta High Court on Monday (November 16) quashed criminal proceedings under Sections 498A and 34 of the Indian Penal Code against a husband, holding that merely failing to answer his wife’s phone calls, without more, does not amount to cruelty within the meaning of the provision [Tanmoy Roy v. The State of West Bengal & Anr.].
Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta allowed the criminal revision filed by the husband, Tanmoy Roy, under Section 401 read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (corresponding to Sections 442 and 528 of the BNSS) and Article 227 of the Constitution. The petition sought quashing of G.R. Case No. 2275 of 2020, arising out of Bagnan Police Station Case No. 431 of 2020 dated December 13, 2020, and the charge sheet dated July 22, 2021, pending before the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Uluberia, Howrah.
The husband’s plea and the State’s reply
The husband told the Court that he was pursuing a PhD in Haridwar and was not living with his wife during the relevant period, and that the main allegation against him was that he did not take her calls while he was outside West Bengal. He also pointed out that coordinate Benches had already quashed the proceedings against his mother and sister after finding the allegations against them vague and omnibus.
The State opposed the plea, arguing that witness statements recorded during investigation disclosed a prima facie case and that the husband should face trial so that the complainant and witnesses could prove the allegations.
The wife’s allegations
The couple married on March 2, 2017, and have a son. In her complaint, the wife alleged that her husband and in-laws subjected her to physical and mental torture after the marriage. She alleged that her mother-in-law and sister-in-law forced her to do household chores, kept from her the documents she needed for a ration card for her son, and repeatedly locked her out of the matrimonial home.
The test under Section 498A
The Court set out the ingredients of the offence:
“The offence, therefore, requires the complainant to be a married woman, subjected to cruelty by her husband or his relatives, and that such cruelty shall fall within clauses (a) or (b) of the Explanation.”
Measured against that, the allegations of physical and mental torture against the husband were found vague and general, since the complaint gave no date, time, place or manner of any act of cruelty. The complaint also disclosed no unlawful demand for dowry or property, ruling out clause (b) of the Explanation.
A call left unanswered
On the only specific grievance against the husband, the Court recorded:
“The sole specific grievance against the petitioner was that he did not answer her calls. The Court finds that this does not amount to cruelty.”
How many calls were made, on which dates, and whether the wife was in any danger or needed urgent help at the time: the complaint said none of this. A student pursuing higher studies outside the State could be in classes, examinations or otherwise busy when a call came, the Court noted, adding:
“A call left unreceived is, by itself, an omission and not an act of wilful conduct.”
Even if every call had gone unanswered, the Court said, such conduct might cause marital discontent but could not be described as likely to drive a woman to suicide or cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health. Section 34 IPC was also held to be without foundation, as the husband was not present when the alleged quarrels with his mother and sister took place.
The mother and sister already discharged
One argument did not find favour: the husband’s contention that the FIR was bad for want of a preliminary inquiry. Citing Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh, the Court said such an inquiry is permissible in matrimonial disputes, but its absence does not by itself invalidate an FIR. It noted, however, that the case against the mother-in-law and sister-in-law had already been quashed on the same general allegations, and held:
“…allowing a similar proceeding to continue against the husband alone would be an abuse of the process of the Court and would result in a miscarriage of justice.”
The revision was allowed and the proceedings, including the charge sheet and all orders passed in them, were quashed insofar as the husband is concerned. A copy of the judgment was directed to be sent to the trial court.
Why the judgment matters
The ruling reiterates that Section 498A requires specific, wilful conduct of the kind described in its Explanation, not general allegations or ordinary marital friction. It also shows courts applying parity where co-accused facing identical omnibus allegations have already been discharged from the case.
Case Title: Tanmoy Roy v. The State of West Bengal & Anr.
Case Number: C.R.R. No. 409 of 2025
Bench: Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta, Calcutta High Court
Date of Judgment: November 16, 2026 (heard on September 22, 2026)
Appearances: Advocates Sabir Ahmed, Partha Sarathi Sarkar, Dhiman Banerjee and Quazi Ezaz Ahmed for the petitioner; Public Prosecutor Kallol Mondal with Advocates Pawan Kumar Gupta and Arijit Bhusan Bagchi for the State
