Allahabad High Court Cuts Father’s Child Education Maintenance, Says Duty Cannot Become Tool Of Oppression

4 min read

Cutting a father’s child education maintenance from Rs 15,000 to Rs 12,000 a month, the Allahabad High Court has held that his duty to educate his daughter cannot be made a tool of oppression, and that both parents’ means must be weighed.

Allahabad High Court building, where a Division Bench reduced a father's monthly child education maintenance

Prayagraj: A father cannot say that his liability for his minor daughter’s upkeep and schooling begins only when he gets custody, the Allahabad High Court has held, while partly allowing his First Appeal and modifying the amount fixed by a family court under Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 [Vipin Kumar Nagar v. Smt. Rakhi Taungar].

A Division Bench of Justice Prakash Padia and Justice Indrajeet Shukla delivered the judgment on November 5, 2026, with Justice Indrajeet Shukla writing for the Bench.

Why custody is no precondition

The father’s main argument was that, as the primary natural guardian of a Hindu minor, his duty to pay maintenance, including school fees, would arise only once custody passed to him. The Bench called this fallacious, noting that he had never sought custody.

Relying on Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of India, it held that the mother can act as natural guardian even during the father’s lifetime and that a preference based on gender would offend Article 15(3) of the Constitution. Maintaining a child is a joint parental duty, and the mother’s employment does not absolve the father; it only bears on each parent’s share.

From a divorce petition to a school fee claim

The couple married on May 3, 2014. Eight years later, the husband filed for divorce under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act. An application under Section 26 read with Section 151 CPC was then moved on behalf of the minor daughter through her mother, claiming Rs 1,00,000 as one-time expenses and Rs 35,000 a month, including Rs 56,000 as admission fees for the fourth standard at a private school in Greater Noida.

The father pleaded that the mother was a clerk at a Central School drawing about Rs 60,000 a month, while he was a clerk at an Inter College drawing Rs 37,504 and had to support his ailing parents and an unemployed younger brother. By order dated August 11, 2023, the family court split the claim, fixing Rs 20,000 against the mother and Rs 15,000 against the father.

The school switch and the mother’s reply

In the appeal, the father said the daughter had been moved out of the Central School, where she was entitled to free education as the single girl child of an employee, only to harass him.

The mother replied that the father had never disputed his liability, that the family court had already placed the larger share on her, and that he had admitted paying loan instalments of Rs 21,780 a month while running a car and was evasive about his income.

Why Rs 15,000 was cut

On the amount, the Court found that the family court had not given due weight to the free education already available:

“The determination of quantum as made by trial Court towards maintenance and educational expenses of a child studying in the Sixth Standard does not appear to be reasonable, particularly when the minor respondent was receiving free education at a Central School and it was the respondent who opted to change the school, without placing any cogent material to demonstrate that the erstwhile school was not meeting the requisite educational standards.”

It added:

“No doubt father being natural guardian is bestowed with the responsibility imparting education in good and repudiated Alma matter commensurate financial and economic viability but same cannot be made a tool for oppression as right to education is a fundamental right but the socio-economic condition of parents are also to be looked into when it comes for adjudication of courts.”

The Bench noted that the father lives in rented accommodation in Gautam Buddh Nagar with his ailing parents and may be repaying a loan, and adopted what it called a balanced and equitable approach. He must now pay Rs 12,000 a month on or before the 7th of every month in place of Rs 15,000, with arrears to be cleared within two months. There was no order as to costs.

What the ruling settles

The ruling settles two points that recur in matrimonial litigation. A father cannot avoid paying for his child’s upkeep and schooling by saying the child lives with the mother, and a working mother’s income does not cancel his duty; it only changes how the burden is shared.

At the same time, the Court has signalled that education costs must be tied to what the parents can realistically afford. Where free, adequate schooling is already available, a parent who opts for a costlier private school must show why, before the other parent can be made to bear the higher bill.

Case Title: Vipin Kumar Nagar v. Smt. Rakhi Taungar [First Appeal No. 998 of 2023]
Bench: Justice Prakash Padia and Justice Indrajeet Shukla, Allahabad High Court
Date of Judgment: November 5, 2026
Appearances: Nanhe Lal Tripathi for the appellant; Anupam Dubey for the respondent

Similar Posts