Delhi High Court Quashes Criminal Defamation Case Against Senior Advocate Pinaki Misra Over ‘Crook’ Remark

4 min read

A criminal defamation case against Senior Advocate Pinaki Misra over a “crook” remark has been quashed by the Delhi High Court, which held that the complainant lawyer failed to show that anyone thought less of him because of it.

Justice Sachin Datta of the Delhi High Court, who quashed the criminal defamation case against Senior Advocate Pinaki Misra.

New Delhi: Advocate Siddhartha Singh‘s Complaint Case No. 11 of 2019 against Senior Advocate and former Lok Sabha MP Pinaki Misra under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code has been quashed by the Delhi High Court on November 17, 2026, which also set aside the 2019 summoning order of the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate-I, Rouse Avenue Courts [Pinaki Misra v. State & Anr.].

Justice Sachin Datta allowed the petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in an oral order. The matter was taken up on November 17 because November 16 had been declared a holiday for Chhath Puja.

Only the complainant was examined

Senior Advocate Rebecca M. John argued that Explanation 4 to Section 499 IPC was not satisfied because the complainant examined only himself. She pointed out that the summoning order was nearly identical to one passed in a connected Complaint Case No. 10 of 2019, which a Coordinate Bench had already quashed on August 25, 2026 in CRL.M.C. 2595 of 2019, and that Singh had stopped appearing before both the High Court and the trial court.

Relying on Jeffrey J. Diermeier v. State of West Bengal and Jaideep Bose v. M/s Bid & Hammer Auctioneers Pvt. Ltd., Justice Datta agreed:

“It is evident that the complaint of the respondent no.2 is predicated on the premise that the publication tarnished his image. However, he has not named any person who read the report or in whose estimation his reputation stood lowered, and he did not examine anybody other than himself at the stage of pre-summoning evidence.”

The August 2026 ruling in the connected case, which arose from a Dailyhunt News publication on the same controversy, “squarely applies” here, the Bench held. It recorded that no one had appeared for Singh on several dates despite a last and final opportunity, and that his 2019 counter affidavit did not address the absence of evidence on harm to reputation.

“It is also noticed that the impugned order does not consider the context in which the words were allegedly used by the petitioner and the dismissal of the complaint by the Bar Council of Delhi.”

How the dispute began

At the relevant time, Misra was a Member of Parliament and Chairperson of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Urban Development. Singh was counsel for the applicant in O.A. No. 122 of 2017, Balbir Singh v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Anr., before the Principal Bench of the National Green Tribunal, where Misra appeared for certain power distribution companies.

Singh objected to that appearance, contending that the Standing Committee chaired by Misra had made adverse recommendations against the same companies on e-waste management. He also filed a professional misconduct complaint before the Bar Council of Delhi on the ground of conflict of interest.

On August 27, 2018, The Economic Times carried a report on that complaint which quoted Misra as saying that the person who had complained to the Bar Council “is a crook”. Singh sent a legal notice on August 31, 2018 demanding an unconditional apology, and Misra replied on September 7, 2018. The Bar Council of Delhi dismissed the misconduct complaint on November 16, 2018.

The criminal complaint under Sections 499 and 500 IPC followed. The magistrate took cognizance on January 15, 2019, recorded Singh as the only witness on February 2, 2019, and summoned Misra on April 20, 2019. The High Court stayed that order on May 15, 2019, and the stay continued until the final decision.

The directions

The summoning order dated April 20, 2019 was set aside, and Complaint Case No. 11 of 2019 and all proceedings arising from it were quashed. A copy of the order is to be sent to the trial court for information and compliance.

Why the order matters

The ruling restates a threshold that magistrates must check before summoning in criminal defamation: the complainant’s own word that his reputation suffered is not enough. There must be some material, at least prima facie, that the imputation lowered him in the estimation of others.

It also shows the weight courts give to consistency. With the twin complaint on the same controversy already quashed, the High Court saw no reason to let the second prosecution continue after more than seven years.

Case Title: Pinaki Misra v. State & Anr. [CRL.M.C. 2617/2019, Crl.M.A. 10470/2019]
Bench: Justice Sachin Datta
Date of Order: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Rebecca M. John with Anushka Baruah for the petitioner; APP Aashneet Singh for the State

Similar Posts