A Durga Puja fund case of forgery, cheating and criminal breach of trust against housing complex residents cannot stand, the Calcutta High Court has held, finding that the investigating agency had collected no material to prima facie establish any of the offences.

Kolkata: Criminal proceedings against residents of a housing complex, who were accused of forging documents and cheating fellow residents while forming a cultural committee and collecting subscriptions for Durga Puja and other social events, have been set aside by the Calcutta High Court. Letting the case continue, the Court held, would amount to an abuse of the process of law [Petitioners v. State of West Bengal & Anr.].
Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das allowed the revisional application and quashed the proceedings arising out of Rajarhat Police Station Case No. 295 of 2024, registered under Sections 406, 419, 420, 465 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code and pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Barasat, North 24 Parganas.
What the investigation never collected
The investigating officer, the Court found, had not seized any document, physical or electronic, to show that the petitioners had manufactured a false document. The promoter’s statement was never recorded, although the complainant questioned the no-objection certificate that the promoter had issued. No bank records were collected to support the alleged siphoning of funds, and the audit report was not collected either, nor was the auditor appointed by the committee questioned. The Court observed:
“It is glaringly visible in the instant case that the investigating authority has failed to collect enough materials to prima facie establish the ingredients to constitute the offences under which the charge sheet has been submitted.”
The essential ingredient of wrongful loss for cheating under Sections 419 and 420 IPC was missing, the Court said, since the complainant had paid no subscription. Nor was there material to show that any property had been entrusted to the petitioners by the complainant and dishonestly misappropriated. Relying on Mohammed Ibrahim v. State of Bihar, it reiterated that forgery requires the making of a false document, and none had been brought on record.
ALSO READ: Karnataka High Court Quashes Section 153A Case Over Repost Of News Clip On Siddaramaiah
How the dispute began
After obtaining preliminary approval, residents of the complex held a general meeting and unanimously decided to form a cultural committee to organise Durga Puja in 2023 and other social and religious events, with a tenure ending on March 31, 2024. The promoter and developer had issued a no-objection certificate by email authorising the petitioners to conduct the annual Puja and other festivals.
One resident later lodged a complaint alleging offences relating to the formation of the committee and the collection of funds. The petitioners said the case was the outcome of a personal dispute and pointed out that the complainant had not contributed any amount to the committee. The Court also noted that the petitioners and other residents had complained against the opposite party on March 18, 2024, alleging threats and criminal intimidation, including a threat to lodge an FIR unless an unconditional apology was tendered. In those circumstances, it said, the possibility of the criminal case being a counterblast could not be ruled out.
Why the Court stepped in before trial
Referring to Rocky v. State of Telangana, the Court acknowledged that the power under Section 482 CrPC must be used sparingly and that disputed facts are not ordinarily examined before trial. This case was different, it held, because the agency had failed to collect even basic material. Applying State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal and Sharif Ahmed v. State of Uttar Pradesh, it found that the chargesheet did not disclose the offences or the evidence against each accused. Apart from the complainant and one other person, no residents were cited as witnesses, and neither the developer nor the auditor was examined.
Holding that the chargesheet was not legally sustainable, the Court quashed the entire proceedings against the petitioners.
Why the judgment matters
Disputes within housing societies over festival committees and subscriptions often spill into police stations. The ruling makes clear that a chargesheet must rest on collected evidence, such as documents, bank records and witness statements, and not merely on the complainant’s account. Where an investigation skips these basics, the High Court can step in at the threshold rather than leave residents to face a trial on a case that cannot stand.
Case Title: Petitioners v. State of West Bengal & Anr. (case number and petitioners’ names to be verified)
Bench: Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das, High Court at Calcutta
Proceedings quashed: Rajarhat PS Case No. 295 of 2024, CJM Barasat, North 24 Parganas
Date of Judgment: To be verified (reported November 19, 2026)
