Is forwarding notices enough to clear Gulbarga Fort Encroachments? Not in the Karnataka High Court’s view: it has told the Archaeological Survey of India to pass formal orders under Rule 38(2) so that the District Magistrate is authorised to demolish the illegal structures.

Bengaluru: The Karnataka High Court on Wednesday directed the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to pass orders under Rule 38(2) of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Rules, 1959 empowering the District Magistrate to demolish illegal encroachments in and around Gulbarga Fort, a centrally protected monument in Kalaburagi [Sharan Desai M.S. v. Superintending Archaeologist and Ors.].
Justice Anu Sivaraman and Justice KS Bharath Kumar, sitting as a Division Bench, gave the direction on November 18, 2026 while hearing a petition pending since 2018.
“That will not do”
The Bench was not satisfied that forwarding copies to the District Magistrate was enough, and explained that the State machinery would act only on a formal order under the Rules. It told the ASI’s counsel:
“That will not do. You have to pass an order in terms of (Rule) 38(2) by which the District Magistrate would be authorized to remove it, without which they won’t remove it… If orders are passed they have to implement it.”
The ASI was asked to take the necessary steps in all such cases so that the District Magistrate is formally required to carry out the demolition.
The petition, and the ASI’s position
The petition was filed by architect and activist Sharan Desai, who seeks removal of illegal structures from the vicinity of Gulbarga Fort. He told the Court that a show-cause notice had been issued to the owners of the illegal structures in 2019 and that an order for demolition of the constructions had been passed later.
For the ASI, Advocate Safalya S Wagle submitted that the Joint Director-General of the ASI had taken the required steps but had received no fruitful response from the State authorities. Copies of the demolition orders sent to the encroachers had also been forwarded to the District Magistrate, he added.
The structure owners’ position is not set out in the hearing record.
Why the hearing matters
Under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 and its 1959 Rules, the ASI can order removal of unauthorised construction around a protected monument, but the physical demolition depends on the district administration. The hearing shows how that division of work can stall enforcement for years: the ASI says it has done its part, while the State machinery waits for a formal order.
By insisting on an order under Rule 38(2) that expressly authorises the District Magistrate, the Bench has tried to close that gap in a case pending since 2018. The outcome will turn on whether the ASI’s order is issued and acted upon.
Case Title: Sharan Desai M.S. v. Superintending Archaeologist and Ors.
Bench: Justice Anu Sivaraman and Justice KS Bharath Kumar, Karnataka High Court
Date of Hearing: November 18, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Safalya S Wagle for the ASI
