A day after visiting the dumping ground at the centre of the case, a Bombay High Court Bench rapped the BMC and the Maharashtra government for cleaning up only when dignitaries visit, and pressed for a Plastic Ban In Mumbai. The remarks were oral, and no written order is yet available.

Mumbai: The Bombay High Court on Wednesday pulled up the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) and the Maharashtra government for carrying out cosmetic clean-up drives only during visits of high-profile dignitaries instead of tackling pollution and waste across the city, and urged an aggressive, total ban on plastic in Mumbai [Kannamwar Nagar Co-op. Housing Society v. State of Maharashtra and Ors.].
Justice GS Kulkarni and Justice Neela Gokhale, sitting as a Division Bench, made the oral remarks on November 18, 2026, a day after the judges personally visited the dumping ground at the centre of the case. No written order on these remarks is yet available.
Why not ban plastic altogether?
The judges expressed surprise that plastic remains in wide use despite the persistent difficulty of treating municipal waste, and asked BMC’s counsel why the corporation could not enforce a complete ban in the city:
“This is the problem of the city. Why, in so far as Mumbai is concerned, not take an aggressive step, not to succumb to any other commercial interests, but to ban in totality plastic? That would be the only way forward so that we save the planet, we save this city.”
Non-biodegradable waste, the Bench stressed, has to be curbed at the source. Every monsoon the sea throws dumped plastic back onto the coastline, it noted, on top of the daily crisis at the city’s dumping grounds.
The State government was directed to clarify its existing policy on plastic and to state whether any other State or Union Territory has implemented a total ban. The Court also asked whether similar prohibitions are enforced at Maharashtra hill stations such as Matheran and Mahabaleshwar. The matter will next be heard on December 7.
Ballard Estate and the “permanent show”
Pointing to the recent transformation of Ballard Estate in south Mumbai ahead of a visit by members of the British royal family, without naming the visitors, the Bench said the administration had shown it could act quickly when it chose to. It told the authorities:
“We just observe, when some guests were coming, see Ballard Estate now, how shining and polished it is. If you want to do it, you do it, including painting, cleaning the streets with water… Do it for citizens. So instead of having this temporary show of two days, have a permanent show. Please have a permanent show in every possible ward. That is the message we want to give you.”
The Bench added:
“If the State government, BMC has a will to do, they can transform things in no time… So, for all these important issues, you are going to be alive only when important personalities visit the city? It may not be appropriate. You have to act for the common man who is the permanent resident of this city.”
ALSO READ: Bombay High Court Moots Forfeiture Of Rehab Homes For Slum Dwellers Who Dump Garbage
How the hearing began
The Bench is hearing a petition by a housing society concerning waste disposal at a landfill in suburban Mumbai. The judges observed that the problem at the landfill appeared closely linked to garbage dumped on the city’s streets and beaches. During their visit on November 17, they flagged mountains of garbage mixed with plastic at the site.
Why the hearing matters
The remarks recast a landfill dispute as a question of how the civic administration chooses its priorities. By contrasting the speed of a pre-visit clean-up with the state of ordinary wards, the Bench has made the point that capacity is not the problem; the will to apply it uniformly is.
The observations were oral and the Court has not yet issued any direction to ban plastic. What it has done is to require the State to set out its policy and the experience of other States, which will frame the next hearing on whether a total ban in Mumbai is feasible. The BMC and the State are yet to respond on the record.
Case Title: Kannamwar Nagar Co-op. Housing Society v. State of Maharashtra and Ors.
Bench: Justice GS Kulkarni and Justice Neela Gokhale, Bombay High Court
Date of Hearing: November 18, 2026
Next Date: December 7, 2026
