Does GST apply to corporate guarantees that a parent or group company gives to a related company without charging a fee? The Delhi High Court has said it does. At the same time, it has read down the valuation rule so that a supplier can prove an open market value below the deemed 1% annual benchmark, and has ruled that a guarantee which stays in force does not become a fresh taxable supply every year.

New Delhi: A batch of petitions challenging the GST treatment of corporate guarantees has been partly allowed by the Delhi High Court, which upheld their taxability but gave relief against an inflexible valuation floor and against retrospective application of the special valuation rule [Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.].
Delivering its judgment on November 17, 2026, when it was pronounced and uploaded, a Division Bench of Justices Anil Kshetrapal and Bharat Parashar held that Rule 28(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 cannot insist on a deemed value of 1% of the guaranteed amount per annum where a lower open market value is established through reliable evidence.
The 1% figure is only a measure for valuing the guarantee service; it is not the GST rate. The Court upheld the statutory power to prescribe the valuation rule, but found an irrebuttable minimum arbitrary under Article 14.
Which guarantees are caught, and from when
A guarantee executed before July 1, 2017 does not attract GST merely because it remained in force after GST began. A later renewal, extension or enhancement has to be examined separately.
Guarantees executed between July 1, 2017 and October 25, 2023 are taxable, but must be valued under the rules then in force. The Court prohibited use of Rule 31 to import the later 1% figure as a uniform valuation measure for this earlier period.
Rule 28(2) governs guarantees executed, renewed, extended or enhanced on or after October 26, 2023. An earlier guarantee does not fall within the rule just because it survives beyond that date. The Court upheld the 2024 amendment’s operation from October 26, 2023.
Why a guarantee without a fee can still attract GST
The petitioners argued that guarantees furnished to protect their investments in subsidiaries were shareholder activities, that no taxable service arose without consideration, and that the valuation rule and its retrospective operation were unlawful. The Revenue maintained that the parent’s credit support enabled borrowing and fell within the GST provisions covering supplies between related persons without consideration.
The Bench held that the service lies in the guarantor assuming the risk of the related company’s default and extending its own creditworthiness to that company. Such support has value from the moment the guarantee is executed, whether or not it is later invoked.
Applying Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I to the CGST Act, the Court identified the related borrower or subsidiary as the recipient of the service. It rejected the contention that the transaction escaped GST as an actionable claim or a security, and distinguished decisions under the earlier service-tax regime, where consideration formed part of the definition of a service.
Proving a value below the 1% benchmark
In paragraph 87, the Court explained that the deemed value must yield to a lower open market value established by the supplier through cogent and verifiable material. The burden lies on the supplier, and the proper officer can test that evidence.
Fair-value measurements under accounting standards, transfer-pricing benchmarks accepted in assessments and pricing based on credit-rating differences were identified as material capable of establishing value. An agreed low fee within the group, or the absence of a fee, does not by itself prove a lower open market value.
The proviso accepting the invoice value where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit was separately upheld. The Court reasoned that full credit makes the transaction revenue-neutral, but stressed that eligibility for such credit is a factual question and cannot simply be presumed because the parties are related.
ALSO READ: Tax Refund Can Be Granted Only When Burden Is Not Transferred: Supreme Court
Execution, renewal and early release
According to the Bench, a guarantee is supplied when it is executed and delivered. Its continuing operation does not turn it into a continuous supply or create a fresh supply every year. A renewal, extension of tenure or increase in the guaranteed amount does create a fresh supply, valued with reference to the additional period or amount, so the same risk is not taxed twice.
For a multi-year guarantee, the tax is to be computed at the time of supply for its entire tenure. The Court left it open to the authorities to provide for collection in annual instalments through an appropriate rule or notification, but did not create an automatic right to pay annually.
Where a guarantee is released early, a supplier may reduce the value attributable to the unexpired period through a credit note under Section 34, subject to its conditions and time limits.
Fresh determination of demands; individual issues remain open
In paragraph 128, the Court set aside the challenged show-cause notices, orders and demands only to the extent that they proceed on a basis contrary to its findings. Proper officers must determine any liability afresh after giving the petitioners an adequate hearing.
Issues including extended limitation under Section 74, share pledges, full input-tax-credit eligibility, proof of market value and the dates or terms of individual guarantees were left open. Taxability of guarantees for recipients outside India before October 26, 2023 was also left for adjudication. The judgment therefore does not extinguish every demand or determine every company’s final liability.
Most petitions were partly allowed. The corporate-guarantee issues in W.P.(C) 15738/2024 and W.P.(C) 12955/2025 were resolved on the same basis, while their additional issues were directed to be listed before the roster bench on December 9, 2026, subject to the Chief Justice’s orders.
Case Title: Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
Case Number: W.P.(C) 2966/2024 and connected matters
CNR: DLHC010095132024
Court: Delhi High Court
Bench: Justices Anil Kshetrapal and Bharat Parashar
Judgment Reserved: October 27, 2026
Judgment Pronounced and Uploaded: November 17, 2026
Status: Batch partly allowed; additional issues in two petitions remain pending.
