Footage Licence Is Not Consent: Why Delhi High Court Found Doosra Rode On Sourav Ganguly’s Persona

9 min read

Licences for archival cricket footage from the BCCI, ICC and others do not amount to Sourav Ganguly’s consent to the commercial use of his persona, the Delhi High Court has held. In its judgment on the Doosra dispute, the Court found that the film used Ganguly’s identity to draw audiences to a fictional story, and that four minutes of footage, emails from 2018 and the label of artistic freedom did not answer that.

Delhi High Court building, where Justice Tejas Karia held that footage licences are not Sourav Ganguly’s consent for Doosra

New Delhi: A licence to use archival footage of a cricket match is not a licence to exploit the personality of the cricketer in it, the Delhi High Court has held while ruling that the film Doosra prima facie infringed the personality and publicity rights of former India captain Sourav Ganguly [Sourav Ganguly & Anr. v. Masha Sajdeh & Ors.].

Justice Tejas Karia delivered the judgment on November 6, 2026 on Ganguly’s application for an interim injunction, after watching the film, its 2019 teaser and its 2026 trailer, and reading the manuscript of Ganguly’s authorised biopic, which was submitted in a sealed envelope. The Court did not stop the film, which had already been released in theatres on October 23. It allowed exhibition to continue on two conditions, a disclaimer and a Rs 2 crore bank guarantee, failing which the film and its promotion would stand restrained.

The parties

The suit was filed by Ganguly and the producer of his biopic, Dada – The Sourav Ganguly Story, which holds rights in his life story under a Life Rights Agreement dated August 5, 2021. Under that agreement, the producer agreed to pay Ganguly Rs 25 crore as fixed consideration, plus shares in branding and box-office revenue. The biopic’s first-look poster was released on July 8, 2026, with a proposed release date of May 14, 2027.

Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 and 6, led by Masha Sajdeh, are associated with the production of Doosra. Defendant No. 5 is its director and Defendant No. 7 is its distributor. Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak appeared for the plaintiffs and Senior Advocate Saurabh Kirpal for the producers and director.

Two stories running in parallel

The makers described Doosra as a docudrama about Tara, a girl growing up in small-town India in a patriarchal household, who struggles with family expectations, marriage and her sexual identity. At each stage of difficulty, they said, the film turns to Indian cricket, then led by Ganguly, overcoming its own hurdles. Ganguly, they argued, appears only as Tara’s source of inspiration and only in his role for the Indian team.

Having viewed the film, the Court found that it “comprises two distinct narratives that proceed in parallel”: Tara’s fictional journey, and Ganguly’s real cricketing journey from his early international career to his captaincy and the 2002 NatWest final win at Lord’s. Tara’s conversations with her family frequently refer to Ganguly’s performance, attitude and achievements. Read with the archival footage, the Court said, these references show that he is “not merely a figure in the historical background, but a recurring reference point through which Tara’s story is advanced and presented.”

Inspiration or appropriation

The Court accepted that a creative work may draw on historical events and public figures, and that placing a fictional story beside such events is not, by itself, an infringement. The distinction it drew was “between the use of a public figure as part of a historical account and the use of the recognition and commercial appeal associated with that individual’s identity and persona to attract interest in the work.”

On that test, it found that the parallel drawn between Tara’s awakening and her courage to stand up to her father, on one side, and Ganguly’s career, his shirtless celebration or a particular match, on the other, “does not arise naturally from the circumstances of the respective narratives.”

“Indian cricket history contains numerous other victories and achievements that could have served as a source of inspiration for Tara without requiring Plaintiff No. 1 to be specifically identified as that source. The association presented at several stages of the Impugned Film is, therefore, one created by the narrative rather than a parallel naturally existing between the fictional and historical events.”

In these circumstances, the Court held, “the invocation of artistic freedom cannot justify the commercial exploitation” of Ganguly’s identity.

Archival footage licences are not consent

The makers relied on a series of licences for archival footage. They included an ICC footage licence of June 2020 for the 1999 World Cup, the 2000 ICC Knock Out and the 2002 Champions Trophy, agreements with Lobster Films and New Delhi Television Limited, a clip licence of October 2021 for the 2002 NatWest final, an August 2026 footage licence with the BCCI, and an AP Archive agreement. The Court drew a clear line between permission to put footage into a film and authorisation to commercially exploit the persona of a person in it.

“The licences granted by the respective copyright owners concern the use of the archival footage and clearly exclude use of any personal rights. Therefore, such licenses cannot, by themselves, be construed as consent on the part of Plaintiff No. 1 to the commercial exploitation of his personality rights.”

Four minutes is not the measure

The makers argued that the footage of Ganguly runs for only about four minutes. The Court held that duration “cannot be treated as the sole or determinative consideration”. What matters is how the identity is woven into the story and whether its recognition is used to generate interest. The plaintiffs had pointed out that about 25 to 27 seconds of the 2 minute 12 second trailer featured Ganguly, and that the promotional synopsis invoked his shirt-waving celebration.

The repeated references to his setbacks, achievements, attitude and persona, and the prominence given to his name and image in the promotional material, cumulatively and prima facie showed, the Court said, an attempt “to derive commercial benefit from Plaintiff No. 1’s identity and ride on coattails of persona of Plaintiff No. 1 without obtaining his authorisation.”

The 2018 emails, and the plea of delay

The makers argued that Ganguly had known about the project since 2017, when the producer’s husband first approached him, and that coming to court nine years later, on the eve of release, disentitled him to interim relief. The Court did not accept this.

It noted that on June 6, 2018, Ganguly’s manager Partha Rudra had written to the producer about “how can a biopic and a documentary on the same person go hand in hand?” That “contemporaneous expression of concern”, the Court said, “itself shows that Plaintiff No. 1 never gave consent”. The correspondence concerned a proposed interview in London for a documentary and remuneration for his time. “At no stage was Plaintiff No. 1 informed that he would be portrayed as the central character in a docufiction cinematographic film.”

Comparing the two promotional videos, the Court found a “marked distinction”. The 2019 teaser, which included an excerpt from an interview between Virat Kohli and Ganguly, suggested a film about Indian cricket seen through a young girl’s eyes. The trailer released on October 12, 2026 and the finished film focused on one player who became captain and led India to the NatWest win. Since the specific use complained of became apparent only with the trailer, the plea of delay and laches was “untenable”. The parties’ correspondence, the Court added, showed that the producer “was aware about the rights of Plaintiff No. 1 rather than acquiescence”.

The Court also noted that Ganguly had told the producer about the proposed biopic in 2018, and that the makers released Doosra “after an unexplained hiatus of nearly seven years, immediately following the announcement of the release of the Biopic”. This, it said, raised a prima facie impression of an intention to commercially exploit his identity ahead of the biopic.

Public record is no answer

On the makers’ reliance on R. Rajagopal v. State of T.N. (1994), the Court accepted that once a matter becomes part of public record, the right to privacy no longer subsists. But Ganguly’s grievance was about the commercial use of his identity, not privacy. His selection as captain when betting allegations had surfaced in Indian cricket, the NatWest win and the shirt-waving celebration are “defining moments” in his journey, and he “is entitled to determine the manner in which his identity and persona are commercially presented through a narrative of his own.”

Why the Court would not cut scenes

The Court considered ordering the removal of the scenes listed by the plaintiffs, but found that Ganguly’s persona is “embedded in the manner in which these narratives are combined, rather than confined to separate portions capable of removal in isolation.” Excising them would require “the dissection, restructuring and reconfiguration of the artistic expression” of the film, which, it said, is not permissible by judicial direction.

The directions

Since the film had already been released, the Court held that the balance of convenience favoured not stopping public viewing at the interim stage, subject to two conditions:

  • within two days, a disclaimer in large font, in English and Hindi, for 5 seconds each at the beginning (immediately after the existing disclaimer) and 2 seconds each at the end before the credits. It must state that the film is not intended to violate or infringe Ganguly’s personality rights, and that the use of his name shall not be construed as his acknowledgment of or consent to such use, which “remains sub judice”; and
  • within two weeks, an unconditional bank guarantee of Rs 2 crore by any of Defendant Nos. 1 to 6, in favour of the Registrar General, as security for the plaintiffs’ rights during the suit.

If either condition is not met, the defendants and all those acting through them stand restrained from exhibiting, streaming, licensing or otherwise exploiting the film in India or abroad, on any platform including OTT. They are also restrained from circulating any trailer, teaser, poster, clip or other promotional material, including the October 12 trailer, that commercially appropriates Ganguly’s name, image, likeness, identity, persona, distinctive celebration, reputation or goodwill.

The distributor had asked that no deposit be directed against it, and the bank guarantee was placed on Defendant Nos. 1 to 6. The Court clarified that its observations are confined to the interim application and are not an opinion on the merits of the suit.

Why the judgment matters

Most personality rights cases in India have concerned merchandise, advertising and AI deepfakes. This judgment applies the doctrine to a feature film that calls itself fiction and uses licensed archival footage. It settles, at least at the interim stage, that a copyright licence for footage and a celebrity’s personality rights are separate, and that the makers must account for both. It also gives filmmakers a working test: a real person may be part of the historical backdrop, but where the story manufactures a link to a living celebrity to sell the film, artistic freedom will not cover that use.

Case Title: Sourav Ganguly & Anr. v. Masha Sajdeh & Ors.
Case No.: CS(COMM) 1156/2026, I.A. 29441/2026
CNR No.: DLHC010511692026
Bench: Justice Tejas Karia
Judgment Reserved: November 2, 2026
Judgment Delivered: November 6, 2026
For the Plaintiffs: Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak with Advocates Jaya Goyal, Manmeet Kaur, Gitika Agarwal, Arjun Agarwal and K.K. Makhija
For Defendant Nos. 1 to 6: Senior Advocate Saurabh Kirpal with Advocates Ameet Naik, Dhruv Anand, Madhu Gadodia and others
For Defendant No. 7: Advocates Shivam Goel, Ramya S. Goel, Sanya Sharma and Ishika Kanyal

Similar Posts