Allahabad High Court Awards Rs 40,000 For Detaining Man To Force Brother’s Surrender; Raps SHO, IO

5 min read

Holding that the police cannot hold an innocent relative as leverage to make an accused give himself up, the Allahabad High Court has awarded Rs 40,000 for the illegal detention of a man kept at a Prayagraj police station for four days while his brother was absconding, directing that the money be recovered from the salaries of the police personnel responsible and that the Court’s displeasure be entered in the service records of the SHO and the Investigating Officer.

Allahabad High Court building, which awarded Rs 40,000 for the illegal detention of a man to force his brother's surrender

Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has granted Rs 40,000 as compensation to Arvind Kumar Yadav, who was picked up from his house in Jaunpur and kept at Police Station George Town, Prayagraj, from June 23 to June 26, 2026, in connection with a case registered against his brother, holding that the police cannot unlawfully detain an innocent family member to coerce an accused into surrendering [Arvind Kumar Yadav (Corpus) and Another v. State of U.P. and 4 Others].

A Division Bench of Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Divesh Chandra Samant disposed of the habeas corpus petition by an order dated September 9, 2026, directing that the compensation be paid by the State and recovered from the salaries of the personnel of the police station responsible for the illegal detention, in such proportions as the State deems fit.

The case

The petition traced back to Crime No. 104 of 2026 at Police Station George Town, registered against the petitioner’s brother, Suresh Kumar, initially under Sections 126(2), 191(2), 352, 115(2) and 75 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, with Section 109 (attempt to murder) added after investigation. The allegations in that case remain to be tested at trial, and the High Court’s order expresses no view on their merits. Suresh Kumar has since been granted anticipatory bail.

Counsel for the petitioners submitted that while the case against the brother would be tried in accordance with law, Arvind Kumar Yadav had nothing to do with it. He was, the petition stated, taken from his house in Jaunpur on June 23, 2026, brought to Police Station George Town and let go only at about 7:00 pm on June 26, 2026. To support this, the petitioners placed on record the Supurdginama executed at the time of his release, which showed that he was handed over on that date and at that time.

Police admission, CDR and CCTV

Appearing before the Bench on its earlier direction, Investigating Officer Ashvani Savita stated that on the instructions of Yogendra Kumar Singh, SHO of Police Station George Town, he and other personnel had gone to the petitioner’s house and picked him up on June 23 for interrogation in connection with the offence. He also told the Court that, while the petitioner was being kept at the police station, his brother was a fugitive from justice until he secured anticipatory bail on August 3, 2026.

The State informed the Court that the investigation had been handed over to Savita on June 24, 2026 from the previous Investigating Officer, Brijesh Kumar Yadav, and did not dispute that the petitioner remained at the police station until his release on June 26.

At the Court’s direction, the Call Detail Record of the petitioner’s mobile phone was produced. It placed him at Badlapur, Jaunpur, in the early hours of June 23, then at Phoolpur in Prayagraj district by 7:02 am and at George Town, Prayagraj, where the police station is located, by 7:56 am. The phone was switched off at 12:11 pm that day and stayed off until 8:08 am on June 27, when it came back on in Jaunpur. CCTV footage further confirmed his presence at the police station from June 23 to June 25, though no footage for June 26 was produced.

Reading this material together with the Supurdginama, the Bench held that the petitioner’s version stood established and that it was undisputed he had remained in the unlawful custody of the George Town police for at least four days, from June 23 to June 26, 2026.

Detention used as pressure

The Court found that although the petitioner had no involvement in the offence, he appeared to have been kept at the police station to bring pressure on his brother and compel him to surrender, a purpose that was in any case overtaken when the brother obtained anticipatory bail in August 2026. Laying down the principle, the Bench said:

“The police cannot resort to pressure tactics to compel the actual offender to surrender before it by unlawfully detaining an innocent member of his family who has no connection with the alleged offence. Such an act on the part of the police would constitute unlawful detention where such a person would be amenable to be compensated for the unjust loss of his liberty, however, temporary it may be.”

Compensation from salaries, displeasure in service records

Holding the petitioner entitled to compensation for his wrongful detention, the Bench awarded Rs 40,000, payable by the State and to be recovered from the salaries of those at Police Station George Town who were responsible for the illegal detention, in proportions to be fixed by the State.

The Court also expressed its displeasure at the manner in which SHO Yogendra Kumar Singh and Investigating Officer Ashvani Savita had conducted themselves towards the petitioner, and directed that this displeasure be duly recorded in their respective service records. With these directions, the habeas corpus petition was disposed of.

Why The Illegal Detention Order Matters

Holding a relative at a police station until a wanted person turns up is a familiar pressure tactic, and the order squarely rejects it as a violation of personal liberty under Article 21. The Bench relied on objective material, the CDR, CCTV footage and the release document, rather than on competing versions, to fix the period of custody, and treated even a short spell of unlawful detention as compensable. By directing recovery from the salaries of the personnel concerned and placing its displeasure on the service records of the SHO and the Investigating Officer, the Court attached personal consequences to the breach rather than leaving the cost to fall on the State alone.

Case Title: Arvind Kumar Yadav (Corpus) and Another v. State of U.P. and 4 Others [Habeas Corpus Writ Petition No. 906 of 2026]
Bench: Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Divesh Chandra Samant, Allahabad High Court
Date of Order: September 9, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Ravi Prakash for the petitioners; Government Advocate for the State

Similar Posts