In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court of India has made a significant ruling in favor of employees’ rights, setting a precedent that could impact employment practices across the country. The court’s decision, which centers on the right of employees to challenge their service conditions if they do not meet statutory requirements, underscores the balance of power between employers and employees.
Also read-BREAKING | Supreme Court Quashes Remission Of 11 Convicts In Bilkis Bano Case. (lawchakra.in)
The bench, comprising Justices U.U. Lalit and Ajay Rastogi, overturned a previous ruling by the Uttarakhand High Court from August 2013. The High Court had dismissed a petition by teachers in the Pharma Science department of a university, who had raised concerns about the selection process based on an advertisement from August 2011 and challenged the terms of their appointment.
In its judgment, the Supreme Court bench stated,
“Indeed, the employer has the full right to impose its conditions, but at the same time, the employee is also free to challenge these conditions’ shortcomings.”
The court emphasized that if an employee’s job is at risk due to challenging these conditions, the court can issue judicial notice in such cases.
The university’s argument, presented by its lawyer, was that the employee had accepted all the terms of the appointment letter and therefore could not challenge them. The Supreme Court bench rejected this argument, stating,
“Your argument should be dismissed because the employee does not get a chance to choose his service conditions. However, when the employer has the right to negotiate on salary and other aspects, the employee also has the right to challenge these conditions if his statutory needs are not met.”
Furthermore, the court observed that the university had attained the status of a Central University in January 2009. Subsequent appointments of teachers in various departments in August 2011 were made under the terms of the UP University Law. The court ruled that for these teachers, the standards of a Central University regarding honorarium, facilities, and other conditions should apply.
This ruling by the Supreme Court is a significant step in reinforcing the rights of employees in India. It acknowledges the importance of fair and equitable employment practices and the right of employees to seek redressal when their statutory rights are compromised. This decision is expected to have far-reaching implications, particularly in the academic sector, ensuring that employment terms are in line with statutory requirements and fair practices.
