An unproven claim of overpayment on one set of contracts cannot be treated as a debt and recovered from money due under other, unrelated contracts, the Supreme Court has held, quashing a Chhattisgarh government agency’s deduction of Rs 84.17 lakh from a road contractor’s running bills without notice or a hearing.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday, September 30, quashed a recovery order by which the Chhattisgarh Rural Road Development Agency withheld Rs 84,17,003 from the running bills of a contractor’s three ongoing Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana works to recover overpayments allegedly made on earlier road works, and directed the State to release the amount with interest at 6 per cent per annum from September 27, 2025 [M/s Awadhesh Singh Gautam v. State of Chhattisgarh and Others].
A Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe, in a judgment authored by Justice Aradhe, set aside the Chhattisgarh High Court’s January 2026 orders, which had declined to interfere on the ground that disputed questions of fact were involved.
Background of the case
The appellant, a partnership firm, was awarded two road contracts in January 2023 at about Rs 437.43 lakh (the earlier works), and three further PMGSY packages under work orders of September 2023 and November 2024 (the subsequent works). Having completed about 40 per cent of each of the subsequent works, it raised running bills of Rs 39.78 lakh, Rs 45.62 lakh and Rs 23.55 lakh, which remained unpaid despite reminders in September 2025.
Following complaints about the earlier works, a five-member committee constituted by the Collector, South Bastar, Dantewada, reported in January 2024 that Rs 3.55 crore had been paid although work worth only about Rs 1.55 crore had been executed, an excess payment of Rs 2.01 crore. The Collector directed recovery through the Tehsildar, and a demand note was issued under Section 146 of the Chhattisgarh Land Revenue Code, 1959. In March 2025, the High Court quashed the demand note for want of notice and hearing, while allowing the authorities to act afresh in accordance with law.
An FIR was also registered on a complaint by an Assistant Engineer of the agency against the firm’s partner, Awadhesh Singh Gautam, and agency officers, and a chargesheet was filed in December 2025. Separately, on September 27, 2025, the Executive Engineer passed the order blocking Rs 84.17 lakh from the three subsequent contracts, in sums of Rs 28 lakh, Rs 38 lakh and Rs 18.17 lakh. The firm’s representation of October 9, 2025 seeking a refund drew no response, and the High Court dismissed its three writ petitions, leaving it to pursue alternate remedies. The allegations relating to the earlier works are yet to be adjudicated.
What the parties argued
Senior Advocate Gaurav Agrawal, for the firm, argued that the recovery order was passed without notice or hearing, in breach of Clause 4.1 of the Special Conditions of Contract, which alone contemplates recovery after a technical audit and only after hearing the contractor. He urged that dues under one contract cannot be appropriated towards a liability under a different contract, and pointed out that about Rs 1.07 crore was still payable to the firm under the very earlier works, yet the State chose to recover from unconnected ongoing contracts. He relied on ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd., (2004) 3 SCC 553.
Additional Advocate General Bishwajit Dubey, for the State, argued that cross-contract recovery is expressly permitted by Clause 7(iv) of the Pre-Contract Integrity Pact, Clause 38 of the Conditions of Contract, and Clauses 44.1 and 53.1(ii) of the General Conditions of Contract. He submitted that the allegation was one of manipulation of measurement books to draw excess public money, not a mere billing discrepancy, and that a contractual set-off is enforceable on the strength of the agreement alone.
None of the clauses supports the recovery
The Court examined each clause relied on by the State. It held that Clause 44.1 deals only with liquidated damages for delay, capped at 10 per cent of the initial contract price, and the recovery order was never founded on delay. Clause 53.1(ii), it said, applies only where a contract is terminated for breach of defects-liability and five-year maintenance obligations, and nothing showed that any of the contracts had been terminated.
As for Clause 7(iv) of the Integrity Pact, the Court held that it presupposes a prior determination that the bidder has violated the pact, and the recovery order neither mentions the pact nor records any such finding. Clause 38, though wide enough to permit recovery from other contracts once validly invoked, is conditional on a breach being first ascertained and communicated to the contractor so that he can meet it; the order recorded no finding of breach and no notice preceded it.
That left Clause 4.1 of the Special Conditions, which the Court found alone answers the description of what the State had done, namely a technical audit followed by recovery of overpayment. It held that the clause permits recovery only from the security deposit or dues under the very work audited, and that the State had not touched the roughly Rs 1.07 crore still due under the earlier works. The clause also requires an opportunity to explain, approval by the CEO of the agency, and action within twelve months of completion. It was common ground that no opportunity was given, the order was issued by the Executive Engineer alone without showing the CEO’s approval, and nothing established the completion date of the earlier works. The Court summed up:
“It follows that none of the clauses relied upon by the respondents, whether read singly or cumulatively, authorises either the deduction of the disputed amount from the three subsequent contracts, or the manner in which it was effected.”
Disputed claim is not a debt
The Court acknowledged that the allegations regarding the earlier works are serious and are the subject of a departmental inquiry and criminal proceedings, and stressed that nothing in its judgment touches their merits. That, it held, does not answer whether the manner of recovery met the conditions of the contract itself. Relying on Union of India v. Raman Iron Foundry, (1974) 2 SCC 231, it observed:
“Until the alleged overpayment is established in accordance with law, it remains, a disputed and unadjudicated claim for damages and not a debt presently due; and a party to a contract cannot, merely because it also holds amounts otherwise payable under it, treat such a claim as though it were an ascertained debt and appropriate those amounts in satisfaction of it.”
The recovery was accordingly held to be not only in contravention of the conditions of Clause 4.1 but also in flagrant violation of the principles of natural justice.
High Court’s approach faulted
The Court held that the High Court erred in treating the case as one turning on disputed facts about the earlier works. The real question, it said, was whether the State could appropriate that disputed amount from money admittedly payable under three unrelated contracts, and that turns on the construction of the contract and compliance with its terms, not on resolving disputed facts.
Directions
Allowing the appeals, the Court quashed the September 27, 2025 recovery order and directed release of Rs 84,17,003 with 6 per cent annual interest from that date until payment. It clarified that the State remains free to pursue appropriate proceedings in accordance with law for any amount ultimately found due on the earlier works, and that its observations are confined to the legality of the manner of recovery, with no bearing on the pending criminal proceedings or on the correctness or quantum of the alleged overpayment, both of which will be decided independently on merits. There was no order as to costs.
Case Title: M/s Awadhesh Singh Gautam v. State of Chhattisgarh and Others
Case Number: Civil Appeals arising out of S.L.P. (C) Nos. 10464, 12766 and 12346 of 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1072
Bench: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe, Supreme Court of India
Date of Judgment: September 30, 2026
Appearance: Senior Advocate Gaurav Agrawal for the appellant; Additional Advocate General Bishwajit Dubey for the State of Chhattisgarh
