Supreme Court Hears Sanjay Raut Contempt Case, Says Apology Must Come From The Heart

4 min read

An apology in a matter of this magnitude must come from the heart and not the mind, the Supreme Court told Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut on Tuesday. In the Sanjay Raut contempt case, the Supreme Court Bar Association asked the Bench to weigh his later social media posts against the apology already on record.

Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi of the Supreme Court, whose Bench heard the Sanjay Raut contempt case

New Delhi: On November 17, 2026, Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut stood before the Supreme Court in the criminal contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over social media remarks about Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and the judiciary, while journalist Nikhil Wagle joined the hearing virtually. The Court said it would go through the material placed before it and pass a comprehensive order on the next date of hearing [Supreme Court Bar Association v. Nikhil Wagle and Another].

A Bench led by Justice Aravind Kumar, which had on October 28 directed Mr Raut to be present in Court at 2 pm today, heard the matter. Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, President of the SCBA, appeared for the Association, and Senior Advocate Indira Jaising appeared for Mr Wagle. The remarks from the Bench were oral, made during the hearing, and no written order on the merits has yet been passed.

In the Bench’s words

Justice Aravind Kumar spoke to Mr Raut directly. The Bench, he said, had listened to his speeches and debates since its own days at the Bar, and he recalled Mr Raut’s long years in Parliament and his background in the press.

“In a matter of this magnitude, apology must come from the heart and not the mind.”

A seasoned parliamentarian of about 25 years who had himself worked in the press, the Bench told Mr Raut, should know what restraint in language means.

What the Association wants weighed

Mr Rai accepted that Mr Raut had expressed an apology but said further posts against the Supreme Court had followed. One carried a picture of the Supreme Court of Albania being set on fire by protesters. He also pointed to posts alleging that the BJP had brought India’s democracy, judiciary, central investigating agencies and the Election Commission under its control, and to an October 11 post about the Leader of Opposition’s planned visit to the Supreme Court and a direction of the Chief Justice on an ED-related meeting request.

Mr Raut’s affidavit, according to the SCBA, says nothing about these later posts. Mr Rai described him as a “habitual offender”, argued that a Member of Parliament holds a respected position from which some responsibility is expected, and urged that the matter be dealt with “with an iron hand”. He also asked for leave to place additional material concerning Mr Raut on record. These are the Association’s submissions; Mr Raut’s detailed response to them was not available at the time of writing.

The plea to discharge Mr Wagle

For Mr Wagle, Ms Jaising said he had stayed present virtually as directed and had filed an affidavit tendering a genuine, bona fide and unconditional apology. He had also deleted the social media post immediately, she submitted, and she pressed for his discharge on the strength of the apology.

The next date

Justice Aravind Kumar indicated that Mr Wagle’s affidavit and the additional material concerning Mr Raut would both be considered before a comprehensive order is passed on the next date of hearing. The personal appearance of the two respondents was also discussed.

The allegations in the petition are the Bar Association’s and remain untested. The Court has expressed no view on whether contempt is made out against either respondent, and both are entitled to be heard fully before any finding is recorded.

How the case got here

Attorney General R Venkataramani gave his consent on October 15, 2026 under Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and the SCBA then filed its petition against Mr Wagle and Mr Raut. A Bench headed by the Chief Justice issued show-cause notice on October 16. On October 28, the Court required Mr Raut to be physically present and allowed Mr Wagle to join virtually.

The question ahead

The hearing raises the question of how far an apology can close a criminal contempt matter when the petitioner says the respondent’s conduct since then points the other way. The Court’s remark that an apology must be sincere rather than tactical, and its decision to look at later material before passing a comprehensive order, frame what it must now decide: where fair criticism of the judiciary by public figures ends and contempt begins, and what weight a written apology carries.

Case Title: Supreme Court Bar Association v. Nikhil Wagle and Another (criminal contempt petition; case number not available)
Bench: Bench led by Justice Aravind Kumar (Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M Pancholi heard the matter on October 28, 2026)
Date of Hearing: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai for the Supreme Court Bar Association; Senior Advocate Indira Jaising for Nikhil Wagle; Sanjay Raut present in person.

Similar Posts