Supreme Court Seeks Centre’s Reply On Lok Prahari Plea To Finalise Judges’ Appointment MoP, Collegium RTI

4 min read

On the Lok Prahari plea to finalise the Memorandum of Procedure for appointing judges and to bring Collegium decisions within the Right to Information Act, the Supreme Court has sought the Centre’s reply.

Supreme Court of India building, where a Bench issued notice on the Lok Prahari plea on judges' appointment MoP.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday issued notice to the Union Government and to the Secretary General of the Supreme Court on a petition by the NGO Lok Prahari seeking directions to finalise the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) for appointing judges to the High Courts and the Supreme Court, and to bring Collegium decisions under the Right to Information Act, 2005 [Lok Prahari v. Union of India].

Justice MM Sundresh and Justice PB Varale, sitting as a Bench, issued notice on November 18, 2026 and allowed the petitioner to file an amended petition.

Ten years without a revised MoP

The MoP was first drawn up in June 1999, after the Second Judges case. On October 16, 2015 a Constitution Bench struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission, and the Court then invited suggestions to make the Collegium system more transparent. By an order of December 16, 2015 it left the task of revising the MoP to the Central government. The revised MoP has not been finalised since, amid disagreements between the Centre and the Collegium.

In October 2017, a Bench of Justices AK Goel and UU Lalit sought the Centre’s response on the delay in a petition by advocate RP Luthra, observing that the issue “cannot linger on for indefinite period”. A Bench headed by then Chief Justice Dipak Misra later recalled that order.

What Lok Prahari wants

The organisation has sought directions to the Chief Justice of India, on the administrative side, to make the changes to the MoP mandated by the 2015 NJAC judgment, and to the Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the MoP within a month after consulting the CJI. It has also argued that appointments to the constitutional courts should rest on a unanimous view of the Collegium, taking into account the factors set out in the NJAC ruling.

The petition says the existing MoP has serious flaws for want of transparency and objectivity, which affect the quality and performance of judges and the litigants’ right to justice. It states:

“Finalisation of the MoP for appointment of judges of constitutional courts at the earliest is necessary to ensure that it meets the requirement of the selection process ensuring that they possess four essential qualities of impartiality, fearlessness, transparency and purity mandated by the Constitution Bench in the case of Chief Election Commissioner and Election commissioners.”

A Collegium member on the Bench

Before taking up the plea, Justice Sundresh wondered aloud whether the Bench should hear it at all, as he is himself a member of the Supreme Court Collegium. “Should we take this matter? Because I am also part of collegium,” he said.

Senior Advocate Sanjay Hegde, appearing for the petitioner, said he had no objection, adding that many judges would be members of the Collegium and “That objection will never go away.” Justice Sundresh then said the Bench would issue notice and remarked that the petition could have been drafted in better words, to which Hegde agreed. The order recorded:

“Issue notice. Petitioner is permitted to file an amended petition.”

The plea had first been listed on November 2, when Justice PS Narasimha recused, citing his earlier appearance as Additional Solicitor General in a similar matter on the MoP.

Why the order matters

The 2015 NJAC judgment kept the Collegium in place but accepted that its working needed reform, and pinned the revised MoP as the vehicle for that reform. More than ten years on, the document remains unsettled, and attempts to push it forward on the judicial side have stalled before. Issuing notice to both the Centre and the Court’s own Secretary General brings both ends of the appointments process before the Bench.

The exchange on whether a sitting Collegium member should hear the case also points to a structural difficulty: any challenge to the Collegium’s working will come before judges who are, or will be, part of it. The Court has so far only issued notice and has expressed no view on the merits of the plea; the petition will be amended before the respondents reply.

Case Title: Lok Prahari v. Union of India
Bench: Justice MM Sundresh and Justice PB Varale, Supreme Court of India
Date of Order: November 18, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Sanjay Hegde for the petitioner

Similar Posts