The Supreme Court has ended State Trading Corporation’s insolvency proceedings against Ganesh Benzoplast, reiterating that an unsecured creditor cannot reopen its full claim once a binding rehabilitation scheme has scaled down its dues. The maximum recoverable under the approved scheme had already been paid.

New Delhi: Nothing remained to be adjudicated once ₹2,18,88,421 had been paid under the rehabilitation arrangement, the Supreme Court has held, restoring the NCLT’s disposal of State Trading Corporation of India’s Section 9 insolvency petition against Ganesh Benzoplast Limited [M/s. Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. The State Trading Corporation of India].
A bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva delivered the reportable judgment on November 16, 2026, with Justice Sanjay Kumar authoring it. It carries neutral citation 2026 INSC 1223.
The Court allowed the company’s appeal, set aside the NCLAT’s January 21, 2026 remand order and restored the NCLT’s February 13, 2020 order. The ruling concerns the effect of this particular sanctioned rehabilitation scheme, not a general entitlement to discharge debts by paying 25%.
Why the scheme bound STC
The NCLAT had accepted STC’s argument that it could not be forced to take the reduced amount and could instead rely on the scheme’s alternative option. The Supreme Court rejected that reasoning. Applying Modi Rubber Limited v. Continental Carbon India Limited and Fertilizer Corporation of India Limited v. Coromandel Sacks Private Limited, it held that a sanctioned rehabilitation scheme binds unsecured creditors as well.
In paragraph 14, the Court held the purported option to wait and later seek full dues invalid. Reopening liabilities after the scheme had worked itself out would expose a rehabilitated company to becoming sick again and undermine the very purpose of the scheme.
How the sanctioned scheme treated unsecured dues
Ganesh Benzoplast, a chemicals manufacturing and storage company, was declared a sick industrial unit by the BIFR in May 2010. A draft rehabilitation scheme was circulated in 2013 and, after the BIFR ceased functioning for want of a member, the Delhi High Court approved the scheme on December 4, 2015.
Clause 11.11 provided for unsecured creditors to receive 25% of principal dues in five equal annual instalments. It also purported to let them reject that reduction and wait until the scheme worked itself out or seven years had elapsed.
STC was not among the listed unsecured creditors. Its claim was recorded separately as a contingent liability, and under the scheme it would acquire unsecured-creditor status only when the claim crystallised. The Supreme Court noted that STC had never challenged that categorisation, and held that being listed as a contingent liability gave it no better position: at most, crystallisation would put it on the same footing as the unsecured creditors entitled to the scaled-down amount.
The demand and the remand
In March 2018, STC demanded approximately ₹24.26 crore under Section 8 of the IBC, covering export and domestic transactions and non-submission of C-Forms. It then sought initiation of insolvency under Section 9.
The company supplied the C-Forms in January 2020. The NCLT quantified 25% of the remaining principal dues at ₹2,18,88,421 and directed payment, disposing of the petition. STC accepted the amount in March 2020 without prejudice to its position.
After an earlier dispute over limitation and a Supreme Court remand for consideration on merits, the NCLAT restored the insolvency petition in January 2026.
The IBC was not a route to quantify the disputed claim
Paragraph 16 records that STC had not taken steps to crystallise its dues before demanding the full amount under the IBC. The Court held that the IBC regime does not provide for determination or quantification of liability through which STC could secure that crystallisation.
Its argument that the company should have paid five instalments beginning in 2015 also failed: the claim had not then acquired the status of an unsecured debt under the scheme.
The C-Forms component had been resolved, and no dispute was raised before the Supreme Court over the NCLT’s quantification of the remaining scaled-down dues. Since STC had already received the maximum recoverable under the scheme, the Court held that reviving its Section 9 petition served no adjudicatory purpose.
The company’s appeal was allowed and the NCLT’s disposal order restored. Each side must bear its own costs.
Case: M/s. Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. The State Trading Corporation of India
Number: Civil Appeal No. 3097 of 2026
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva
Date: November 16, 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1223
Outcome: Appeal allowed; NCLAT remand set aside and NCLT’s disposal of the Section 9 petition restored.
