The Consumer Commission has directed Honda to replace a motorcycle due to a manufacturing defect, marking a significant decision in consumer rights advocacy. The ruling came despite the absence of an expert report, with the Commission’s coram, comprising presiding member Milind S Sonawane, and members Nisha A Chavhan and Nagesh C Kumbre, pointing to the repeated repair attempts as indicative of inherent manufacturing flaws.
Also Read- PMLA Court Denies Former CM Hemant Soren’s Request To Attend Jharkhand Budget Session (lawchakra.in)
The case centered around a consumer’s complaint regarding his Honda motorcycle, which he claimed had a persistently malfunctioning suspension system since purchase. Despite six repair attempts, the issue remained unresolved. The consumer’s grievances were compounded by the dealership’s dismissal of the problem, attributing it to low tire pressure, and Honda’s partial repair approach that only addressed the rear suspension, leading to back problems for the owner.
The Commission’s scrutiny revealed that the District Commission had erred in its factual assessment. The repeated need for repairs was seen as clear evidence of a manufacturing defect. The judgment emphasized the consumer’s expectation of comfort from the vehicle, which was unmet, leading to mental, physical, and financial distress.
The Commission’s statement,
“But in the present case, vehicle is repaired by the respondents on so many occasions from the beginning. This fact shows that there is a manufacturing defect in the vehicle from the beginning and there is no need to call any expert report,”
underscores a pivotal stance on consumer protection. It highlights the responsibility of manufacturers to ensure the quality and reliability of their products.
This decision not only mandates Honda to replace the defective motorcycle but also sets a precedent for how manufacturing defects are recognized and addressed in consumer goods, especially in the absence of expert analyses. It reinforces the principle that consumer welfare is paramount and that companies must uphold the highest standards of product quality and customer service.
The ruling by the Consumer Commission serves as a reminder to manufacturers and dealerships of their obligations to consumers, emphasizing the importance of addressing legitimate complaints promptly and effectively. It also empowers consumers, affirming their rights to demand accountability and quality in the products they purchase.
Case title – Markad Mahesh Aasaram v Fine Honda Dealer and Anr
Also Read- Delhi Court Denies Bail To Tasleem Ahmed In 2020 Riots Conspiracy Case (lawchakra.in)
