J&K High Court Quashes PSA Detention, Says Mere Claim Of VPN Contact With Terrorist Insufficient

5 min read

A PSA detention order whose grounds read as a copy of the police dossier, and which alleges VPN contact with a terrorist handler without dates or particulars, cannot stand, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court has held in directing the release of a 26-year-old Pulwama driver.

Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court building at Srinagar, where a PSA detention over vague VPN terror contact claims was quashed

Srinagar: Grounds of detention that mirror the police dossier show that the detaining authority did not form its own satisfaction, the Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has found while setting aside a Public Safety Act detention order passed against a driver accused of acting as an Over Ground Worker for terrorists, and directing his release [Ajaz Ahmad Seh v. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir and Another].

Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal allowed the habeas corpus petition (HCP 279/2025) on October 30, 2026, quashing Order No. 34/DMP/PSA/2025 dated July 28, 2025, passed by the District Magistrate, Pulwama under Section 8 of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978.

Dossier and grounds, side by side

Laying the police dossier next to the grounds of detention, the Court found them “couched in substantially identical language”. That, it said, gave rise to a clear inference that the District Magistrate had not independently assessed the material. Citing its earlier ruling in Noor-ud-Din Shah v. State of J&K (1989 SLJ 1), it held that “the requirement of subjective satisfaction is not fulfilled merely by reproducing the allegations in the form of grounds of detention.”

Stressing that it did not minimise allegations involving terrorist organisations, the Court said “a perfect balance has to be maintained between the protection of the security of the State and the preservation of personal liberty.”

The case against the driver

The grounds of detention described the petitioner, a resident of Sehpora in Rajpora tehsil, as being in contact with a person described as a Jaish-e-Mohammad handler through a telephone number and the encrypted application Zangi, allegedly accessed through a secured VPN, to communicate with handlers in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir and Pakistan.

The authorities further alleged that he was an Over Ground Worker who provided food, shelter, clothing, transport and information to active terrorists, passed on information about security force movements, and was being encouraged to join terrorist ranks. The grounds also referred to bonds he had executed under Sections 126 and 170 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 on April 21, June 4 and July 4, 2025. The order rested on a dossier from the Senior Superintendent of Police, Pulwama, and he was lodged in District Jail, Udhampur.

These remain allegations made by the detaining authorities. They have not been tested in any trial, and the petitioner is entitled to the presumption of innocence.

What each side urged

For the petitioner, it was argued that the allegations rested on presumptions and conjectures, that the grounds merely replicated the police dossier, that the relied-upon documents were not supplied, and that the grounds were served in technical English he could not follow, having studied only up to Class XII. It was also contended that the alleged conduct, even if accepted, could be dealt with under the ordinary criminal law.

The Government Advocate maintained that the District Magistrate passed the order on independent subjective satisfaction, that the safeguards under Article 22(5) of the Constitution and Section 13 of the Act were complied with, that the grounds were read over to the detenue in a language he understood, and that he never filed a representation.

No dates, no content, no specific acts

The Court accepted that the allegations were serious. But the grounds, it found, did not disclose the dates of the alleged communications, what information was exchanged, or the specific acts of logistical support. It held:

“The mere assertion that the detenue used an encrypted application or a VPN, or remained in contact with persons alleged to be associated with terrorist organisations, cannot, without further particulars and relevant supporting material, furnish an adequate basis for curtailing personal liberty through preventive detention.”

It added that “general assertions, however grave in tenor, cannot be permitted to take the place of specific and intelligible grounds capable of being meaningfully answered.”

The route the grounds left unexplained

Relying on Rekha v. State of Tamil Nadu and Vijay Narain Singh v. State of Bihar, the Court said that if the agency had material showing electronic coordination of terrorist activity, it could have investigated and prosecuted under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 or other penal laws. The grounds did not explain why that route was inadequate.

“Preventive detention legislation cannot be permitted to become an instrument for bypassing the safeguards of the ordinary criminal process or for detaining a person on the strength of allegations that remain insufficiently particularised.”

As for the three bonds under the BNSS, the Court said they were at most background circumstances and could not by themselves establish the need for detention.

Release ordered

The petition was allowed and the detention order quashed. The respondents were directed to release the detenue forthwith, unless his custody is required in any other case or under any other lawful order. The detention record was returned to the State’s counsel.

Why the judgment matters

Preventive detention under the PSA is frequently used in Kashmir on allegations of militant links. The ruling makes clear that invoking the security of the State in general terms is not enough: the grounds must give dates, acts and material the detenue can actually answer, and the detaining authority must explain why prosecution under the ordinary law, including the UAPA, would not suffice. It also reiterates that a District Magistrate who copies the police dossier into the grounds has not applied an independent mind.

Case Title: Ajaz Ahmad Seh v. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir and Another
Case No.: HCP 279/2025
Bench: Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal, High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar
Date of Judgment: October 30, 2026 (reserved October 22, 2026)
For the Petitioner: Advocates Mohammad Ayoub Bhat and Mahajabeen Bhat
For the Respondents: Jahangir Ahmad Dar, Government Advocate

Similar Posts