A strong prima facie case, a favourable balance of convenience and likely irreparable injury were not enough for Section 9 relief after an arbitral loss, the Delhi High Court has held, refusing interim protection to Kimti Lall Jain in a Suez dispute because the additional requirement of a rare and compelling case had not been established.

New Delhi: Applying the higher threshold governing Section 9 relief for a party unsuccessful in arbitration, the Delhi High Court on November 18 declined Kimti Lall Jain’s interim request to preserve court deposits connected with a past-retention-money dispute involving Suez group entities [Mr Kimti Lall Jain v. Suez Water Technologies and Solution & Ors.].
Justice Tushar Rao Gedela refused the interim prayer while keeping the petition pending. It will be listed on December 14, 2026 alongside Jain’s Section 34 challenge to the arbitral award.
A strong case that still fell short
The Court left the disputed contractual interpretation and alleged breaches for the Section 34 proceedings. In its interim assessment, however, it rejected the unsupported oral characterisation of the deposits as mere top-up payments and treated them as past retention money.
Paragraphs 50 and 51 record the Court’s assessment of the financial documents and its findings that Jain had shown a strong prima facie case, that the balance of convenience favoured him and that he was likely to suffer irreparable injury without protection.
The higher bar after an award
In paragraph 52, the Court applied Home Care Retail Marts Pvt. Ltd. v. Haresh N. Sanghavi & Ors., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 670, and its own decision in Thor Ventures. An unsuccessful party can invoke Section 9 after an award, but protection requires rare and compelling circumstances. A strong prima facie case alone does not meet that additional requirement.
Paragraph 53 finds that Jain’s arguments were substantially grounds for challenging the award rather than circumstances satisfying that exceptional threshold. The Court considered that the efficacy of the Section 34 challenge was not diluted or compromised and noted that the holding-company respondents were already parties, leaving further proceedings or execution available if his challenge succeeded.
How the dispute arose
The dispute arose from the acquisition of two Driplex companies promoted by Jain and his family. Shares were transferred in two stages, with the final transfer completed in March 2019. Certain payments relating to earlier contracts remained unrecovered.
The parties entered into a supplementary framework agreement governing recovery and sharing of this past retention money. A later general agreement dealt with powers of attorney needed to pursue recovery. They disagreed over the recovery period, delays in issuing those powers and Jain’s entitlement to amounts recovered or deposited after the stipulated period.
An arbitral award dated April 18, 2026, corrected on June 8, rejected some of Jain’s claims and partly allowed others. He challenged the adverse portions under Section 34. For the interim relief considered in this order, he restricted his request to four deposits made by third parties in proceedings concerning awards obtained in favour of the Driplex companies. The order records deposits totalling Rs 38,91,62,075.
What each side argued
Jain argued that the deposits resulted from his recovery efforts, fell within the contractual retention-money arrangement and needed to be preserved while his award challenge was decided. He also relied on financial records indicating losses and limited assets of the target companies.
The respondents argued that the relevant claim had already been rejected, that the contractual recovery arrangement had expired and that no rare and compelling circumstances justified securing a rejected money claim. They also disputed whether the evidence established a post-award risk of dissipation.
The interim prayer was therefore denied. The respondents were given three weeks to file a reply, with a rejoinder before the next hearing. The order neither dismisses the pending award challenge nor finally determines Jain’s monetary entitlement.
Case Title: Mr Kimti Lall Jain v. Suez Water Technologies and Solution & Ors.
Case Number: O.M.P.(I) (COMM.) 354/2026 and I.A. 22929/2026
CNR: DLHC010394222026
Court and Bench: Delhi High Court; Justice Tushar Rao Gedela
Reserved: November 3, 2026; Delivered: November 18, 2026
Status: Interim prayer denied; petition pending, next listed December 14, 2026 with O.M.P. (COMM) 355/2026
