Supreme Court Asks If Ex-Mutawalli Can Keep Representing Malkhed Dargah As Sajjadanashin After Tenure Expires

4 min read

Whether a former Mutawalli can go on representing the Malkhed Dargah in court by claiming to be its Sajjadanashin, after his term as caretaker has ended, is a question the Supreme Court has now agreed to examine, listing the waqf dispute for further hearing on November 25.

Supreme Court of India, which will examine whether a former Mutawalli can represent the Malkhed Dargah as its Sajjadanashin.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has agreed to examine whether a person whose tenure as Mutawalli (caretaker) of a waqf has expired can continue to represent the waqf in legal proceedings by claiming that he is also its Sajjadanashin (spiritual head of the shrine), in an appeal against a Karnataka High Court judgment in a dispute concerning the Malkhed Dargah [Dargah Hazrat Khalifat-ur Raheman Rehmat-Ulla-Alia (Sunni Malkhed) v. Syeda Ahmedia Banu @ Ahmedunissa Begum & Ors.].

A Bench of Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Vijay Bishnoi framed the question while hearing a plea challenging the judgment of the Karnataka High Court’s Kalaburagi Bench, and listed the matter for further hearing on November 25, 2026, seeking assistance from the petitioner’s counsel.

How the dispute reached the Supreme Court

The Dargah had filed a suit before the Waqf Tribunal seeking a declaration that certain properties were waqf properties. The Tribunal dismissed the suit on the ground that the person representing the Dargah no longer held the post of Mutawalli, his tenure having come to an end.

The High Court set aside that dismissal. It held that the suit had been instituted in the name of the waqf institution itself and should not fail merely because the Mutawalli’s tenure had ended, and it directed that the proceedings continue through the Waqf Officer.

The petitioner’s case

Before the Supreme Court, the petitioner contended that he was entitled to keep representing the Dargah because he was also its Sajjadanashin, an office that, unlike the appointment of a Mutawalli, carries no fixed tenure. Senior Advocate Sudhanshu Choudhari appeared for the petitioner.

The question framed by the Bench

The Bench noted that the petitioner had not relied on any waqf deed or pleaded any custom establishing his position as Sajjadanashin in the original proceedings, and framed the issue as follows:

“What is relevant to be considered is whether in absence of any Waqfnama or a Waqf deed, and in absence of any custom pleaded in the plaint/application preferred before the Tribunal by the petitioner of him being the Sajjadanashin of the Dargah concerned, having accepted his appointment as a Mutawalli, could he continue to represent the Waqf/Dargah on expiry of his term as the Mutawalli.”

The Court has only framed the question at this stage and has expressed no final view on whether the petitioner can represent the Dargah or on the waqf character of the properties in dispute.

Why the hearing matters

Under waqf law, the Mutawalli manages the waqf’s properties and affairs, often for a fixed term set by the waqf deed or by the Waqf Board, while the Sajjadanashin is the spiritual head of a dargah, an office frequently held for life or by hereditary custom. The two roles are often held by the same person, which can blur who has the authority to sue or defend on behalf of the institution.

The answer will decide who may speak for a dargah in litigation once a Mutawalli’s term runs out, and whether a claim to be Sajjadanashin must be grounded in a waqf deed or a custom pleaded at the outset. That carries weight for many waqf suits pending before tribunals, where challenges to the standing of the person in charge can stall disputes over waqf property.

Case Title: Dargah Hazrat Khalifat-ur Raheman Rehmat-Ulla-Alia (Sunni Malkhed) v. Syeda Ahmedia Banu @ Ahmedunissa Begum & Ors.
Bench: Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Vijay Bishnoi, Supreme Court of India
Next date of hearing: November 25, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Sudhanshu Choudhari with Advocates Preetam Shah and Aanchal Rathore, and AOR K. Krishna Kumar, for the petitioner; AOR Pritha Srikumar Iyer, Advocates Armaan Rai, Shariq Ahmed, Sunil Kumar Verma, Tariq Ahmed and M Shaz Khan, and M/s Ahmadi Law Offices (AOR), for the respondents

Similar Posts