Without ruling on its validity, the Allahabad High Court has rejected a plea to void the 1968 Krishna Janmabhoomi compromise between the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sangh and the Trust Shahi Masjid Idgah, saying the question cannot be decided without a full trial.

Prayagraj: The deity-plaintiff side’s bid to have the October 12, 1968 land-sharing compromise over the Katra Keshav Dev complex in Mathura declared “null and void”, and the 1973 and 1974 decrees of a Mathura court passed on its basis cancelled, failed in the Allahabad High Court on November 20, 2026, which clarified that it was not ruling on the validity of the compromise [Shri Bhagwan Shrikrishna Lala Virajman & 4 Ors. v. U.P. Sunni Central Waqf Board & 3 Ors.].
Justice Avnish Saxena decided four applications in Original Suit No. 7 of 2023, one of 18 suits pending before the High Court on the Krishna Janmabhoomi-Shahi Idgah dispute. All four were dismissed. Orders were reserved on October 13, 2026.
Why a trial is needed first
The relief sought through the application, the Court noted, is also the main relief in some of the connected suits concerning the same property, so it could not be granted without a trial. Treating the application as misconceived, it held:
“The same is devoid of merit and hence, dismissed without effecting the merit of other suits, as the application is not taken up on its merit.”
The terms of the 1968 agreement
The agreement was entered into between the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sangh and the Trust Shahi Masjid Idgah. It divided the disputed land within the 13.37-acre complex and asked the two sides to stay out of each other’s areas. It was filed in Civil Suit No. 43 of 1967, which was decreed in its terms by judgments dated July 20, 1973 and November 7, 1974.
Under its terms, the northern and southern walls of the Idgah’s “Kachchi Kursi” were to be extended eastward up to the railway line, the Idgah Trust was to get occupants outside those walls vacated and hand that land to the Seva Sangh, and the Seva Sangh was to give up any claim to the land inside the northern walls. The agreement records that the Idgah Trust had obtained the Waqf Board’s permission by a letter dated September 9, 1968.
What the plaintiffs argued
The plaintiffs contended that the Seva Sangh and the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust are separate legal entities. According to them, Seth Jugal Kishore Birla created the Janmabhoomi Trust by a trust deed of March 9, 1951 and endowed the Katra Keshav Dev property to it, while the Seva Sangh was formed separately in 1958 and had no ownership rights or authority to give up any part of the land.
The Janmabhoomi Trust, they argued, was not a party to the 1967 suit or the compromise, and they alleged that the Seva Sangh wrongly presented itself as the same entity. Besides the declaration and cancellation of the decrees, they sought vacant physical possession of the premises at Khasra No. 255, Deeg Gate, Mathura, for the deity.
The three other applications
A plea by plaintiff no. 1, the deity, to implead the direct descendants of Thakur Keshav Dev Ji, members of the Jadaun clan and others as parties was also refused. The Court pointed out that the deity is already represented by its next friend, Kaushal Kishore Thakur Ji:
“It is the interest of the plaintiff in the suit, who is a deity, which is the point of concern in respect to the cause of action and the relief sought. There is nothing in the application or in the arguments of learned counsel to show the gainful purpose for which other plaintiffs be included in the suit.”
Plaintiffs 2 to 5 sought to recall an earlier order refusing to remove Kaushal Kishore Thakur Ji as next friend; that plea was rejected for want of any ground. Another application by plaintiffs 2 to 5 sought modification of the August 1, 2024 order of Justice Mayank Kumar Jain, which had rejected the defendants’ Order VII Rule 11 CPC applications in 15 suits, mainly to add the name of a counsel at certain places. The Court held that the changes sought were neither clerical or arithmetical errors nor accidental slips, and dismissed it.
Why the order matters
The validity of the 1968 compromise is one of the main questions raised across the connected suits in the Mathura dispute. By declining to rule on it through an interlocutory application, the High Court has kept that question open for decision at trial on evidence, without any finding for either side.
The order also limits efforts to widen the array of parties or rework earlier orders in the batch, which may help the suits move toward trial.
Case Title: Shri Bhagwan Shrikrishna Lala Virajman & 4 Ors. v. U.P. Sunni Central Waqf Board & 3 Ors. [Original Suit No. 7 of 2023; Applications 132Ga2, 114Ka2, 56Ga2 and 72Ga2]
Bench: Justice Avnish Saxena
Reserved On: October 13, 2026; Delivered On: November 20, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Reena N. Singh and Anil Kumar Singh argued the applications for the plaintiffs; Advocates Afjal Ahmad, Azim Ahmad Kazmi, Hare Ram, Nasiruzzaman, Pranav Ojha and Punit Kumar Gupta for the defendants
