Fresh Interest Claim Cannot Be Raised In Closed Writ Case: Supreme Court Grants Retired Bank Employee Rs 5 Lakh Relief

3 min read

The Supreme Court has clarified that a fresh interest claim cannot be pursued through a miscellaneous application in a finally decided writ petition. Yet, invoking Article 142, it directed Central Bank of India to pay a retired employee an additional Rs 5 lakh after decades of litigation, finding that his separate interest claim had earlier been rejected on an untenable ground.

Supreme Court of India building, where a fresh interest claim in a closed writ case was held not maintainable.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on November 18 granted limited monetary relief to retired bank employee Ashok Kumar while affirming that he had chosen the wrong procedural route to pursue interest after a later writ petition was dismissed [Ashok Kumar v. Central Bank of India & Ors.].

Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu directed payment of Rs 5 lakh as full and final settlement of Kumar’s dues against the bank. Justice Datta authored the judgment.

Decades of proceedings before the interest dispute

Kumar joined the bank in 1969 and was suspended in 1978 following allegations of defalcation. His criminal acquittal became final in 1991. He challenged departmental proceedings that year, succeeding before the High Court in 2007, when it quashed the inquiry and directed reinstatement, if he had not retired, with consequential benefits.

The bank’s challenge ultimately failed in the Supreme Court in July 2011. Kumar had retired in March 2009 while still under suspension. Payments totalling about Rs 42 lakh were subsequently recorded in the contempt proceedings.

He filed a fresh writ petition in 2015 seeking compound interest on delayed salary arrears. After it was rejected in December 2023, he sought interest through a miscellaneous application in his original, already concluded writ case. The High Court rejected that application and his intra-court appeal.

A later cause of action is different from reopening an old case

Paragraph 20 distinguishes the original challenge to disciplinary proceedings from the subsequent interest claim arising from litigation-related delay. The Court held that a judgment on an earlier cause of action does not bar a claim based on a later one. The fresh writ petition was therefore the proper proceeding, and its dismissal on the ground adopted by the Single Judge was untenable.

But Kumar should have appealed that dismissal. He could not instead use a miscellaneous application in the original case to obtain substantive relief on the new cause of action.

Paragraphs 21 and 22 explain that such applications have a limited, ancillary role, including correcting clerical errors, clarifying ambiguities or addressing implementation. They cannot become a route to fresh adjudication or a merits review that bypasses the requirements governing review. The rejection of Kumar’s miscellaneous application was therefore legally correct.

Article 142 relief in the particular circumstances

The Court nevertheless found that Kumar’s separate interest claim should have received consideration on its merits. It referred to interest as a normal accretion on capital, rather than a penalty, and to the principle that an act of court should not harm a litigant.

Considering his prolonged litigation and advanced age, the Bench exercised Article 142 to direct the additional Rs 5 lakh payment. It did not award the compound interest rates he had demanded.

The amount must be paid within two months from production of a copy of the judgment before the bank’s competent authority. It constitutes full and final settlement of his dues. The appeal was disposed of on those terms.

Case Title: Ashok Kumar v. Central Bank of India & Ors.
Case: Civil appeal arising from SLP (C) No. 29916 of 2024
Citation: 2026 INSC 1242
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu
Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026
Status: Final judgment; appeal disposed of with Rs 5 lakh additional payment under Article 142

Similar Posts