Allahabad High Court Faults Colonial-Era UP Police Rules, Mandates Hearing Before Opening History Sheets

6 min read

Calling police surveillance without a chance to be heard a breach of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution, the Allahabad High Court has held that a citizen must be given a hearing before opening history sheets against him.

Allahabad High Court building, which mandated a hearing before police open history sheets in the Rais Ahmad case.

Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has quashed the Class-A history sheet kept for years against a Moradabad man who was acquitted in every case once registered against him, and has directed the Uttar Pradesh Government to amend its procedure so that anyone the police propose to put on a Class-A or Class-B history sheet first gets an opportunity to file objections [Rais Ahmad v. State of U.P. and 3 Others].

The criminal writ petition was allowed on November 17, 2026 by a Division Bench of Justice Siddharth and Justice Vinai Kumar Dwivedi, with Justice Siddharth authoring the judgment. The order had been reserved on October 15, 2026.

What the Court ordered

The central direction of the judgment reads:

“It is high time that this practice should be stopped and before opening of history sheet of Class-A or Class-B against any citizen of the State, he should be given one opportunity to submit his objection before it is accepted by higher official of the police and before such officer directs opening of any Class of history sheet against a citizen. While directing opening of history sheet of Class -A and Class -B, the higher police authority shall record his reasons for directing opening of history sheet of any Class after considering the objection of the citizen filed against the report of the police station.”

The State Government must examine the procedure and issue the amendments or guidelines needed to let a person object before the senior police official. It must also provide for a yearly review of history sheets, so that where persons are later exonerated or acquitted, their history sheets are closed and the “shadow of surveillance by police on their life and liberty gets removed”. The Registrar (Compliance) was asked to communicate the order to the Principal Secretary (Home), Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow, within one week.

As for the petitioner, the Court quashed the history sheet opened against him and directed that his surveillance be stopped forthwith.

Pre-Independence rules, post-Constitution rights

Looking at the U.P. Police Regulations, the Bench said they were framed before Independence for “subject Indians” and contain no requirement of natural justice. Once the Constitution came into force, it said, compliance with Article 14 became imperative wherever life, livelihood and liberty are involved. Describing what a history sheet does, the Court observed:

“By opening history sheet the police gets the right of surveillance of the history sheeter. Whether the police report submitted before the higher police authority for approval is correct or not is not considered nor the person sought to be made a history sheeter is ever afforded opportunity to put his version against the police report. After opening of Class-B history sheet, the history sheeter remains under surveillance for life and his right to liberty is severely effected in the name of surveillance. He is vulnerable to police dictate, threat and coercion throughout his life.”

Subjecting a citizen of a sovereign democratic State to such surveillance could not be in accordance with Articles 14 and 21, the Court added, and “Such a person is condemned unheard.” It noted that the DGP’s 2022 guidelines cover the opening and review of Class-A history sheets but not Class-B, which leaves the police with what it called absolute power to open Class-B history sheets “on any pretext”. Because of the possibility of false implication over personal and political rivalry, the Bench held that the provisions needed review, observing that the police were acting against the mandate of Articles 14, 19 and 21 on the basis of pre-Independence regulations.

The man behind the petition

Rais Ahmad had asked the Court to quash Entry No. HS-22A in History Sheet Register No. 8 at Police Station Chandausi, District Moradabad, and to restrain the police from making domiciliary visits to his home.

According to the petition, he was implicated in several criminal cases in 2005 under the Indian Penal Code, the Arms Act and the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, and acquitted in all of them. He said his name nonetheless stayed on the Class-A history sheet, police personnel kept visiting his residence, and he had not been implicated in any case for nearly two decades.

The State opposed the plea. Its case was that the history sheet was opened because of the petitioner’s criminal antecedents, that he was acquitted only because no one dared to depose against him, and that surveillance was therefore necessary. It also argued that he had an alternative remedy of a representation to the Superintendent of Police.

What the record showed

From the record, the Bench noted that the petitioner had been acquitted in the criminal cases as well as in the Gangsters Act proceedings, and that no criminal case was pending against him when the history sheet was opened. It referred to the Director General of Police’s communication of November 3, 2022, which said history sheets should not be opened routinely, only for habitual offenders needing intense surveillance, and that implication under the Gangsters Act or the Goonda Act could not by itself be a ground.

The State, the Court found, had placed no reasoned order on record to show that the mind was applied before the history sheet was opened against the petitioner.

Why the judgment matters

History sheets have long worked as an internal police tool, opened on a station-level report and approved by a senior officer without the affected person ever learning the basis. The ruling places that step within the guarantee of natural justice under Article 14 and the right to liberty under Article 21, requiring notice, a chance to object and a reasoned decision before a citizen is placed under routine police watch.

The direction for an annual review answers a common grievance as well: entries that outlive acquittals for years. If the State frames guidelines as directed, history sheets in Uttar Pradesh will need a recorded justification at the start and periodic scrutiny afterwards, rather than lasting indefinitely.

Case Title: Rais Ahmad v. State of U.P. and 3 Others [Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 21793 of 2026; 2026:AHC:234948-DB]
Bench: Justice Siddharth and Justice Vinai Kumar Dwivedi, Allahabad High Court
Order Reserved: October 15, 2026
Date of Judgment: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Prarabadh Jain for the petitioner; Additional Government Advocate for the State

Similar Posts