Courts Cannot Rehear Arbitration On Merits: Supreme Court Rejects Rajasthan Power Utility’s Challenge To Coal-Mining Awards

4 min read

The Supreme Court has rejected Rajasthan’s power-generation utility’s challenge to arbitral awards in favour of Parsa Kente Collieries, stressing that a plausible interpretation of a contract cannot be displaced merely because a court prefers another view. It also rejected the use of an unraised limitation plea to undo an additional award.

Supreme Court of India building, where the court held arbitration awards cannot be reheard on merits in a coal-mining dispute.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has dismissed Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd.’s special leave petition against a Rajasthan High Court judgment restoring two arbitral awards in a coal-mining and delivery dispute [Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Limited].

Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh delivered the judgment on November 16, 2026. The written decision was uploaded on November 17. It leaves intact the awards dated January 15 and July 5, 2021.

What the arbitration concerned

RVUNL and Parsa Kente Collieries Limited entered a Coal Mining and Delivery Agreement in 2008 for the Parsa East and Kanta Basan coal block. Following cancellation of coal-block allocations and the block’s reallocation to RVUNL, the parties continued their arrangement through a supplementary agreement.

The arbitration covered payments for coal, fresh mining-lease stamp duty, interest on overdue payments, legal expenses, bank-guarantee charges, additional rehabilitation obligations, a vocational training centre and increased land-acquisition costs.

The Commercial Court set aside both awards after rejecting findings on some claims. The Rajasthan High Court reversed that order on May 21, 2026, holding that the Commercial Court had exceeded the limits of Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

Exceptional intervention under Article 136

The Supreme Court explained that arbitral litigation should ordinarily reach finality at the Section 37 stage. Article 136 remains available, but its use is discretionary and exceptional rather than another routine appeal.

Paragraph 10 summarises the limits: a Section 34 court cannot sit in appeal over an award, while a Section 37 court cannot undertake its own merits assessment or reappraise evidence. A plausible contractual interpretation remains primarily the arbitrator’s domain.

Patent illegality must reach the root of the award. Findings based on no evidence, irrelevant material or disregard of vital evidence may justify interference, but a different possible interpretation or mere error in applying law is not enough.

Claim-by-claim scrutiny within limited grounds

The Bench examined all nine claims to test the objections raised. It emphasised in paragraph 47 that this was a check on the statutory limits of review, not a fresh determination of the underlying commercial dispute.

For coal consumed before adverse quality reports arrived, it found the arbitrator’s interpretation permitting payment to be a possible view. It also declined to disturb the award concerning ₹83.47 crore in stamp duty and other charges for a fresh mining lease, holding that the Commercial Court had substituted its construction of the agreement for the arbitrator’s permissible reading.

The Court likewise found no basis to interfere with findings concerning additional project-affected families and the vocational training centre. Its conclusions turned on the contractual allocation of work and obligations; they do not impose a general reimbursement rule for every mining contract.

Unraised limitation plea could not defeat additional award

The additional award granted ₹66.70 crore for increased land-acquisition costs in four villages. The arbitrator had omitted that part of the claim from the original award, which separately rejected a claim concerning a fifth village as premature.

In paragraph 43F, the Court accepted that the omitted claim could be addressed through an additional award. It also held that limitation involved facts and correspondence relevant to when the claim accrued. RVUNL had not raised that plea before the tribunal. In the absence of the necessary factual foundation and pleadings, the Commercial Court should not have used it to set aside the award.

Because no part of either award was found invalid, the Court rejected the request for a remand to examine severability. It left the separate cross-objection question unanswered, having heard RVUNL on every claim, and dismissed the special leave petition without costs.

Case: Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd. v. Parsa Kente Collieries Limited
Case Number: SLP(C) No. 32968 of 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1234
Bench: Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, Supreme Court of India
Judgment Date: November 16, 2026; uploaded November 17, 2026
Outcome: SLP dismissed; High Court’s restoration of the award and additional award remains intact.

Similar Posts