The Madras High Court has refused to discharge a former Tamil Nadu Minister and his family in a disproportionate assets case, holding that under the unamended Prevention of Corruption Act no sanction under Section 19 was required to prosecute a public servant who had already demitted the office he is alleged to have abused. It also held that no sanction under Section 197 CrPC arises, as a disproportionate-assets offence has no nexus to official duty.
The Supreme Court has acquitted a Patwari, since deceased, in a Prevention of Corruption Act bribe-trap case, holding that proof of both the demand and the acceptance of illegal gratification is a sine qua non for conviction under Sections 7 and 13 of the Act. With the complainant having died before deposing and the shadow witness turning hostile, no witness saw the demand or the handing-over of the money, and the recovery of tainted currency alone could not sustain the conviction.
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has dismissed a State appeal against the acquittal of a Patwari in a 1996 bribery-trap case, holding that the recovery of tainted currency is not, by itself, proof of guilt under the Prevention of Corruption Act. A demand for gratification, and not a mere demand for money, must be proved beyond reasonable doubt before the statutory presumption under Section 20 can be invoked. Finding the evidence pointed as plausibly to a demand for government dues, and the acquittal not perverse, the Court affirmed it.
The Kerala High Court has granted the State two days to file its objection to former DGP Tomin J. Thachankary’s plea to suspend his four-year sentence, imposed on his conviction in a disproportionate assets case, pending his appeal against the conviction. The State described the matter as an exceptional case given the high office he held; the Court observed that there is no absolute right to object where the sentence is under ten years. The conviction is under appeal.
A railway parcel clerk caught in a 1995 trap accepting a Rs 100 bribe to book a motorcycle, and convicted in 2004, has had his conviction upheld by the Jharkhand High Court, which found the demand and acceptance of illegal gratification proved on the Neeraj Dutta standard. But given that the case had run for three decades, the appellant is now over 75 and ailing, it was his first offence and he had already lost his job, the Court reduced his sentence to the statutory minimum.
Acquitting a former Railway Protection Force officer convicted of taking bribes for transfers and postings through intermediaries, the Supreme Court held that proof of money reaching an intermediary does not, by itself, establish that the public servant demanded or accepted it. It stressed that approver testimony needs independent corroboration, and that the Section 20 presumption arises only once the foundational facts of demand and acceptance by the accused are proved.
The former NSE Managing Director argued that officers of a private company cannot be public servants under the Prevention of Corruption Act. The Supreme Court declined to interfere with the Delhi High Court’s rejection of that argument, holding that whether she was discharging a public duty is a question she can raise at trial.
The Supreme Court held that the Section 20 presumption under the Prevention of Corruption Act cannot be drawn unless the initial demand is proved, acquitting two public servants in a 1996 bribe case. New Delhi: The Supreme Court has acquitted a former village Talati-cum-Mantri and a peon in a 1996 bribery case, holding that the […]
A bribery case from Bihar stunned the Supreme Court after the defence claimed rats had destroyed the seized bribe money. The bench said, “We were surprised the recovered notes were destroyed by rats.”
The Supreme Court has ordered a CBI probe into allegations of favouritism in allotment of public works contracts to firms linked to Arunachal Pradesh Chief Minister Pema Khandu’s family. The Court directed the CBI to begin a preliminary enquiry within two weeks and submit a status report within 16 weeks.
