The Patna High Court acquitted three men sentenced to life for a 2005 murder in Jamui, holding that the injuries recorded in the post-mortem did not match the weapon and body part named in the FIR, the weapons were never seized, no blood or site plan supported the place of occurrence, and the prosecution’s case rested on the word of the informant alone.
The Patna High Court acquitted a man sentenced to life for the 2005 murder of a boy in Khagaria, holding that the FIR was lodged after the body was found and named no one, the claimed eyewitnesses were examined after delays of 12 days to nearly two months, and the Investigating Officer was never examined.
The Patna High Court acquitted Ranjit Mahto, sentenced to life for a 2005 double murder in a bus firing in Begusarai, holding that the sole eyewitness was not wholly reliable, an injured witness and a jail register contradicted her presence, Section 34 IPC could not bridge the gap, and the police investigation was lacking.
The Patna High Court acquitted Rajesh Gupta, sentenced to life for the 2003 kidnapping and murder of a 10-year-old boy in Saharsa, holding that the alleged extra-judicial confession was never put to him under Section 313 CrPC, the last-seen evidence was weak, the motive flimsy, and the Investigating Officer was never examined.
The Patna High Court acquitted Pradeep Mahto, sentenced to life for a 2007 murder in Begusarai, holding that the FIR was antedated, the police suppressed the first version given by the deceased’s wife, the claimed eyewitnesses were not eyewitnesses, and the investigation was completely deficient.
The Patna High Court ruled that media can report criminal proceedings but should avoid labels like “mastermind” or “kingpin” that suggest guilt before trial. Justice Ansul said prejudicial reporting may harm an accused’s reputation and amount to defamatory or improper conduct during pending cases.
