Patna High Court Acquits Life Convict In Begusarai Toddy Murder Case; Finds FIR Antedated, Widow’s Statement Suppressed

4 min read

The FIR was antedated, the widow’s first account was kept out of the record, and none of the so-called eyewitnesses actually saw the shooting, the Patna High Court has found, acquitting a Begusarai man sentenced to life for a 2007 murder near a toddy palm.

Patna High Court building, illustrating: Patna High Court Acquits Life Convict In Begusarai Toddy Murder Case; Finds FIR Antedated, Widow's Statement Suppressed

Patna: The Patna High Court has set aside the conviction and life sentence of Pradeep Mahto for the 2007 shooting of a toddy-tapper in Bakhri, Begusarai, holding that the prosecution version was “fabricated and antedated”, that the police suppressed the initial account of the deceased’s wife, and that the investigation was so deficient that the prosecution case could not stand on its own legs [Pradeep Mahto v. State of Bihar].

A Division Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar Singh and Justice Ansul, in a judgment authored by Justice Ansul, allowed the 2010 appeal and discharged the appellant, on bail since July 2011, from his bail bonds.

The case

According to the FIR lodged by Pawan Sada on March 25, 2007, his father Sukho Sada, who drew and sold toddy from leased palm trees, went with him and a relative to a palm tree that afternoon. The appellant, a neighbouring shopkeeper, allegedly arrived and quarrelled with Sukho Sada over the theft of clay toddy pots, then ran home, returned with a pistol and shot him in the neck. In March 2010, the Additional District and Sessions Judge-IV, Begusarai convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

‘Eyewitnesses’ who saw nothing

Of the 14 prosecution witnesses, all the independent witnesses turned hostile. Examining the rest, the Court found that every witness who claimed to have seen the shooting conceded otherwise in cross-examination. Satan Sada, named in the FIR as the person with the deceased, said he was up the palm tree and only saw Sukho Sada lying shot when he came down. Ashok Sada and Etwari Sada admitted they reached the spot after hearing that Sukho Sada had been killed. The informant himself said in cross-examination that he went to the spot with his mother and others after Satan Sada came back shouting about the killing.

The Court held that these were not improvements needing formal contradiction under Tahsildar Singh, but “inherent contradictions” where the witness’s own cross-examination undid his examination-in-chief, so that “no reliance can be placed on any witness claiming himself to be an eyewitness.”

FIR antedated, widow’s version suppressed

The Court found that the police reached the spot on their own information, that the formal FIR was lodged at 11 PM, yet the inquest report prepared at 5:45 PM already bore the FIR number. One witness said the deceased’s wife, Khakhri Devi, had told the officer-in-charge that her husband had been threatened by criminals a week earlier, and that police took her statement at the spot, but her statement appears nowhere in the case diary. The Bench concluded:

“This clearly shows that the FIR does not contain the first version of the incident and the version that has come up on record is a fabricated and antedated version which seems to have been created after much consultation.”

Acknowledging that the delay was only seven hours, the Court held that the suppression of the widow’s version, the antedating of the inquest report and the FIR reaching the Magistrate only on March 28, despite Section 157 CrPC requiring it to be sent forthwith, together robbed the prosecution of the spontaneity of a genuine first information. It relied on Thulia Kali v. State of Tamil Nadu, Meharaj Singh v. State of U.P. and Chhotkau v. State of U.P.

Drawing an adverse inference under Section 114(g) of the Evidence Act for the non-examination of the widow, the Court said she was a witness “essential to the unfolding of the prosecution case”, particularly where several persons had falsely claimed to be eyewitnesses.

A ‘completely deficient investigation’

The Investigating Officer admitted he found no fallen toddy, clay pot or footprints at the spot, did not send the seized blood to the forensic laboratory, and learnt of the incident “through a rumor.” No murder weapon, clothes or empty cartridge were seized. The defence’s case was that the deceased was killed by miscreants who had threatened him, and that the appellant, with whom the family had prior animosity, was falsely implicated; the informant also admitted in cross-examination that he had taken possession of 12-13 kattha of the appellant’s land after the killing.

Holding that, given the serious doubts over the FIR, the eyewitness claims and “a completely deficient investigation,” it had “no option but to disbelieve the entire prosecution case which is not able to stand on its own legs,” the Court set aside the conviction of March 25, 2010 and the sentence of March 29, 2010, and acquitted the appellant.

Case Title: Pradeep Mahto v. State of Bihar [Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 438 of 2010]
Bench: Justice Sanjay Kumar Singh and Justice Ansul, Patna High Court
Date of Judgment: October 1, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Raj Kumar, Rajnish Kumar and Sarvottam Kumar for the Appellant; APP Dilip Kumar Sinha for the State

Similar Posts