A Karkardooma court has acquitted five men in the 2020 North-East Delhi riots mosque arson case at Allah Wali Mosque, Karawal Nagar, holding that police eyewitnesses were not credible and the CCTV footage was inadmissible without a valid Section 65B certificate.
Both witnesses disowned the message in court, and the Supreme Court has held that a Disputed WhatsApp Message Cannot Sustain Murder Conviction in a case that rested wholly on circumstantial evidence. New Delhi: Setting aside a Chhattisgarh man’s conviction for murder and causing disappearance of evidence, the Supreme Court has acquitted him, observing that a […]
The Rajasthan High Court has upheld a trial court’s decision to allow a bank cheque-return memo, first exhibited without the bank’s seal and signature, to be produced again with them and marked afresh, in a cheque-dishonour case under the Negotiable Instruments Act. Marking a document as an exhibit, the Court held, does not by itself prove its contents or authenticity; that must still be established at trial, where the accused can test it in cross-examination.
Allahabad High Court refused DNA test plea, holding Section 112 Indian Evidence Act, 1872 ensures legitimacy if spouses had access. Justice Nand Prabha Shukla stressed social parentage over biological proof.
The Kerala High Court ruled that a daughter born within four months of marriage is legally presumed to be legitimate and entitled to an equal share in her father’s property. The Court set aside a trial court decree, holding that conception before marriage does not defeat the presumption of legitimacy under law.
The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal seeking substitution of a legal heir, holding that a Will cannot be treated as genuine when the only attesting witness admitted, “I do not know the contents of my chief affidavit” and “I do not know the contents of the will.” The Court emphasized that even the slightest doubt about an attestor’s credibility makes proving a Will extremely difficult.
The Supreme Court of India ruled that a narco-analysis test cannot be conducted without an accused’s consent, reinforcing constitutional protections against self-incrimination. It emphasized that results from such tests cannot solely convict someone. The court criticized prior approvals for involuntary tests, asserting the need for safeguard measures if conducted voluntarily.
The Supreme Court of India acquitted six murder suspects, criticizing the “overzealous” police investigation and highlighting that a significant number of witnesses turned hostile, including the victim’s son. The court emphasized that convictions must rely on valid evidence, not on assumptions or inadmissible statements, leading to the reversal of the Karnataka High Court’s ruling.
New Delhi, Feb 24 – The Supreme Court of India has ruled that a child witness is a competent witness and their testimony cannot be rejected outright just because they are young. The bench, comprising Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, emphasized that the Indian Evidence Act does not specify any minimum age for a witness. If a child is found capable of understanding and answering questions, their evidence is legally admissible.
BJP leader Suresh Nakhua requested more time to rectify a flawed affidavit in his defamation case against YouTuber Dhruv Rathee. Rathee sought the case’s dismissal, emphasizing Nakhua’s repeated errors. The court noted procedural issues and scheduled a hearing for February 2025, awaiting clarification on the affidavit’s compliance with new legal requirements.
