Former Supreme Court judge Justice Abhay Oka has said there is no impropriety in Justice Bhuyan’s remarks on mass disenfranchisement, since a judge may speak on national issues as a citizen so long as he does not comment on a pending case or order. New Delhi: Former Supreme Court judge Justice Abhay S. Oka has […]
Justice Ujjal Bhuyan of the Supreme Court said any process disenfranchising millions of citizens is intrinsically arbitrary, violates Articles 14 and 326, and that Article 326 cannot be tinkered with by any authority or condoned by any court.
Former Supreme Court judge Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman has said the Election Commission cannot function as it has during the Special Intensive Revision, called government control over the appointment of Election Commissioners a red flag, and urged the Supreme Court to decide the challenge to the 2023 CEC Act at the earliest.
Today, On 24th February, The Supreme Court, hearing claims of Aadhaar misuse for Rohingyas in West Bengal, said, “This needs a deeper probe and the court is not a forum for this.” It advised advocate Ashwini Upadhyay to approach the Union government.
Today, On 24th February, In the West Bengal SIR case, the Supreme Court of India permitted deploying civil judges and seeking officers from nearby states From Odisha & Jharkhand. It said even if each judge handles 250 cases daily, the verification would still need eighty days.
Today, On 4th February, WB CM Mamata Banerjee told the Supreme Court in the SIR case that the Election Commission is a “WhatsApp Commission” targeting Bengal before the polls, urging the Court to save democracy as she alleged bias in voter list actions while the CJI suggested a way forward.
Today, On 4th February, The Supreme Court told the Election Commission of India to issue name discrepancy notices carefully during Mamata Banerjee’s plea against the West Bengal SIR. Banerjee said the state was being targeted and delivered an emotional statement in court.
The Supreme Court cautioned that revision of electoral rolls can seriously affect civil rights if names are excluded from voters’ lists. Hearing challenges to the Election Commission’s SIR exercise, the Court said electoral powers cannot be “untrammelled” and must follow due process.
Yogendra Yadav has filed a PIL in the Supreme Court challenging the ECI’s voter list revision in Bihar, claiming it is arbitrary and unjust. He argues it could disenfranchise millions, particularly marginalized groups, due to stringent document requirements. Yadav alleges this violates fundamental rights and requests immediate intervention to protect voters.
An NGO has approached the Supreme Court challenging the Election Commission’s special voter roll revision in Bihar. It warned that due process flaws and tight deadlines may lead to lakhs of genuine voters being disenfranchised.
