Supreme Court Directs CBI To Probe Financial Irregularity Allegations Against Indiabulls Promoters

4 min read

The Supreme Court directed the CBI to investigate financial irregularity allegations against the promoters of Indiabulls Housing Finance (now Sammaan Capital), despite the EOW’s exonerating report.

Supreme Court of India, which directed the CBI to probe financial irregularity allegations against the promoters of Indiabulls Housing Finance

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday directed the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) to investigate allegations of financial irregularities levelled against the promoters of Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited (now Sammaan Capital Limited), holding that the agency should conduct the probe notwithstanding a substantially exonerating report filed by the Delhi Police’s Economic Offences Wing (EOW) on five of the six allegations [Citizens Whistle Blower Forum v. Union of India, SLP (C) No. 2993/2025].

A Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana passed the order, deeming a holistic probe by a premier agency necessary. The allegations remain untested, and the order is one for investigation rather than any finding of wrongdoing.

The order

The Court directed the CBI to investigate the allegations regardless of the EOW’s report on five of the six matters, and separately instructed the EOW to complete its remaining investigation on the sixth allegation and file a status report. On the sixth allegation — which the ASG said related to a case involving ₹1,575 crore — the Court directed the trial court to decide the CBI’s pending application seeking permission for further investigation, in accordance with law, within two weeks.

The order was passed in a public interest litigation alleging serious financial misconduct by the promoters, including the round-tripping of funds, the siphoning of money and violations of the Companies Act. At an earlier stage, the Court had sharply criticised both the EOW and the CBI over their failure to apprise it of the progress of the investigation.

The competing submissions

Appearing for the CBI and the EOW, Additional Solicitor General S.V. Raju informed the Court that the EOW was investigating five of the six allegations, and that the CBI had not investigated the same set because two agencies cannot investigate identical allegations. On the sixth allegation, he said, a chargesheet had already been filed, and the CBI had moved the Special Court seeking permission for further investigation.

For the petitioner, Advocate Prashant Bhushan contended that the EOW was not competent to conduct the investigation, submitting that under an RBI circular, all bank frauds above ₹50 crore must be probed by the CBI. He argued that the EOW’s “exoneration” rested on a report by the company’s own chartered accountant and on the claim that the original loans had been returned — which, he submitted, “does not absolve the company.”

Opposing him, Senior Advocate Narender Hooda submitted that there was no “bank fraud” at all, pointing out that no bank had come before the Court to say that money had not been repaid.

The Court’s observations

The exchange drew two notable observations from the Bench. When Justice Bagchi noted that the EOW had given a substantially exonerating report, Bhushan pressed that the exoneration was founded on the company’s own auditor’s account. On the petitioner’s contention regarding the alleged evergreening of loans — the practice of extending fresh credit to enable the repayment of existing debt so that a loan does not show as in default — Justice Bagchi observed that the evergreening of loans is not, by itself, a crime.

Those observations frame the limits of the order: the Court has directed a fuller investigation by the CBI without endorsing the allegations, and has signalled that not every practice complained of is necessarily criminal — questions that the investigation, and any proceedings that follow, will have to work through.

Background

Indiabulls Housing Finance, one of India’s larger housing-finance companies, was rebranded as Sammaan Capital Limited following a change in its promoter and ownership structure in recent years. The present proceedings arise from a PIL by the Citizens Whistle Blower Forum alleging financial misconduct by the company’s erstwhile promoters, and have run alongside investigations by multiple agencies, including the Enforcement Directorate, whose prosecution complaint identified the six allegations now at the centre of the dispute over which agency should investigate them.

The Court’s order resolves that jurisdictional tangle in favour of a CBI-led probe, while keeping the EOW’s remaining work and the trial court’s decision on further investigation on track. Nothing has been established against the company or its promoters, and the directions are confined to how, and by which agency, the allegations are to be investigated.

For the Petitioner: Prashant Bhushan, Adv., with Neha Rathi, AoR
For the Respondents: Mukul Rohatgi, Narender Hooda, Rakesh Dwivedi and Dr. A.M. Singhvi, Sr. Advs.
For the CBI/EOW: S.V. Raju, ASG

CASE: CITIZENS WHISTLE BLOWER FORUM v. UNION OF INDIA, SLP(C) No. 2993/2025

Similar Posts