Can a first appellate court throw out an electrocution compensation claim because the incident looks doubtful? Not without weighing the evidence, the Supreme Court has said, restoring ₹8.70 lakh with 6% interest to a woman who lost her right hand. It held that suspicion, without a proper evaluation of the witnesses and evidence, cannot undo a trial court’s findings.

New Delhi: A woman whose claim that a live transmission wire caused her injuries was dismissed on appeal has had her compensation decree restored by the Supreme Court, which held that a civil claim must be decided on evidence and not on a court’s doubts about whether an incident could have happened [Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited & Ors.].
The reportable judgment was delivered on November 16, 2026 by a bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar, with Justice Shree Chandrashekhar authoring it. It is reported as 2026 INSC 1216.
Rekha’s appeal was allowed and the Rajasthan High Court’s May 10, 2024 decision set aside. The trial court’s decree for ₹8,70,000, with interest at 6% until payment, stands restored.
How the High Court read the case
The High Court had treated the incident as suspicious. It relied on inconsistencies concerning the hanging wires, noted the delay in reporting the matter to police, questioned proof of the supporting documents and dismissed the compensation suit.
The Supreme Court saw the claim differently. Rekha’s case rested primarily on witness testimony, with medical records and other documents serving as supporting material, and her evidence remained intact on the material aspects of the claim.
Probability, not certainty
Paragraph 10 of the judgment explains that civil cases are governed by preponderance of probability. The evidence need not establish the claim beyond reasonable doubt, but it must show a fair degree of certainty rather than a mere possibility.
Not every inconsistency or omission is material, the Court emphasised. A first appellate court has to assess the evidence, and it cannot substitute its own suspicion for findings built on witnesses whom the trial court found credible.
Paragraph 12 recognises grounds on which an appellate court may interfere, among them material irregularity, reliance on inadmissible evidence or a misreading of evidence. Suspicion alone, without weighing the truthfulness of the witnesses, is not enough.
The accident, and two accounts of it
Rekha was a minor at the relevant time. She said she suffered electric shocks on July 15, 2011 after coming into contact with a live transmission wire that hung three to four feet above the ground on a village route. By her account, the wires had been sagging for several days and she tried to move one out of her way.
Serious burns followed, and her right hand was amputated after further treatment at Agra. A civil suit seeking compensation was brought on her behalf.
The electricity utility denied negligence and disputed her version. It suggested that she had instead been shocked at home while handling a jumper wire. Those were the respondents’ contentions, and the Supreme Court examined them against the trial evidence.
A defence witness who saw nothing
Rekha testified about the accident and held to her account in cross-examination. Her witnesses backed her version and said complaints had been made about the dangerously low transmission wires.
The utility’s employee, who put forward its alternative account, admitted that he had not witnessed the incident and was not even on duty that day. He also accepted that maintaining the transmission lines was the respondents’ responsibility.
In paragraph 8, the Supreme Court found that the defence led through this witness was hearsay. The respondents could have produced positive evidence that the lines were properly maintained and positioned, but they did not establish that they were not responsible for the incident.
Strict liability and the final order
The bench cautioned against hunting for minor faults to unsettle a trial judgment. A delay in lodging a claim or complaint, or some inconsistency in the plaintiff’s evidence, does not by itself justify discarding an otherwise established case.
Paragraph 13 holds that the matter attracted the respondents’ strict liability and that the High Court should not have interfered. The existing compensation decree was restored; the Court did not order a fresh trial or a fresh assessment of damages.
Case: Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited & Ors.
Number: Civil Appeal No. 14202 of 2026, arising from SLP (Civil) Diary No. 42323 of 2025
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar
Date: November 16, 2026
Citation: 2026 INSC 1216
Outcome: Appeal allowed; trial court’s compensation decree restored.
