The Karnataka High Court suggested that the State introduce mandatory police verification for migrant workers employed as domestic helps. The Court said proper background checks and public awareness can help prevent crimes while ensuring migrant workers are not stigmatized.
The Karnataka High Court has recently observed that the State government should introduce clear guidelines for regulating and verifying the background of migrant workers who are employed and allowed to stay in private homes.
A Bench comprising Justices HP Sandesh and Venkatesh Naik made this observation while hearing a criminal appeal related to a triple murder and robbery case. The Court expressed concern over several instances where migrant workers employed in private homes were allegedly involved in serious crimes such as murder and robbery.
The judges noted that many employers hire domestic workers without conducting any proper verification of their identity, background, or criminal history. According to the Court, this lack of verification has created situations where offenders manage to escape after committing crimes.
“In many such cases, the house owners or employers had engaged the workers without conducting any background verification, identity confirmation, or registration with the concerned authorities. Some of such migrant workers frequently committing crimes and fleeing away and as such, the same have to be streamlined by issuance of certain guidelines by the State Government. This situation highlights the urgent need for preventive safeguards through strict enforcement of existing labour and criminal regulatory mechanisms,”
the Court said.
ALSO READ: Telangana Considers Legislation for Social Security and Protection of Domestic Workers
Considering these concerns, the High Court suggested that the State government should introduce a structured vetting system. Under such a system, police authorities may conduct background checks before migrant workers are allowed to stay at the homes of their employers.
The Court also stressed the need for awareness among the public regarding safe hiring practices. It suggested that citizens should be encouraged to verify workers properly before employing them.
“A structured and mandatory police verification mechanism should be introduced before engaging workers who reside within private premises, similar to tenant verification systems, with simplified online registration portals accessible to the public. At the same time, widespread public awareness campaigns through print, electronic, and social media platforms should be undertaken to educate citizens about safe hiring practices,”
the February 27 ruling said.
At the same time, the Bench made it clear that such measures must not lead to discrimination or stigma against migrant workers. The Court emphasised that criminal acts are committed by individuals and cannot be attributed to an entire group of workers.
“However, while strengthening preventive mechanisms, it is equally important to ensure that migrant workers are not stigmatized as a class, since criminal liability is individual in nature and the constitutional guarantees under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India protect the dignity and equality of all persons. Thus, balanced judicial directions aimed at regulation, awareness, and accountability without discrimination which would serve the larger interest of public safety and social justice,”
the Court said.
The Court made these observations while delivering its judgment in a case involving the murder of three members of the Sachidev family in Bengaluru. The victims were Professor Purushotham Lal Sachidev, his wife Rita Sachidev, and their son Munna Sachidev.
According to the prosecution, the family had hired a domestic worker, Suchitra Haldar. She allegedly conspired with her husband Deepak Haldar and their associates Mohammed Sarbal alias Raj and Bidan Shikari to rob and murder the family.
The crime occurred in 2009. During the incident, the accused allegedly murdered all three family members and stole gold, cash, and other valuables from the house.
The Court therefore emphasised the need for a structured regulatory system to help authorities track and verify workers more effectively.
“In this case, the migrant labours who were from West Bengal came to Bengaluru in search of job, entered the house of deceased persons as maid, they made criminal conspiracy, committed murder of deceased persons (three deaths) and robbed gold, silver and other valuable properties in their house and fled away. They were arrested after twenty months of the incident … there was difficulty in tracing and securing the accused persons. In this regard, streamlining of the aforesaid guidelines is very much required. Thus, we hereby direct the State Government to take a call on this issue,” the judgment said.
The Bench directed that a copy of its observations be sent to the Chief Secretary of the Karnataka government so that the State can consider framing appropriate guidelines for background verification and safe hiring practices.
ALSO READ: Prajwal Revanna Appeals Life Sentence in High Court Over Domestic Worker Rape Conviction
Investigators later discovered that Suchitra Haldar and her husband Deepak Haldar, who had been living in an outhouse on the victims’ property, had suddenly disappeared after the crime.
The police eventually traced the couple to West Bengal, recovered the stolen valuables, and arrested them. During interrogation, the couple confessed to their involvement in the crime and named other accused persons who had participated in the conspiracy.
Two of the remaining accused were later arrested, while another accused continued to remain absconding.
Initially, a trial court had acquitted the four arrested accused due to lack of sufficient evidence. However, the State government challenged the acquittal before the Karnataka High Court.
After reviewing the evidence, the High Court concluded that the prosecution had successfully proved the guilt of the accused.
“We are of the considered opinion that the prosecution has proved the guilt of the accused persons beyond reasonable doubt,”
the High Court ruled.
The Court subsequently convicted all four accused and sentenced them to life imprisonment for the offences of triple murder, robbery, and criminal conspiracy.
During its judgment, the Bench also pointed out the practical challenges faced by law enforcement agencies when accused migrant workers commit crimes and then flee to their home States, making investigation and arrest difficult.
The Court therefore emphasised the need for a structured regulatory system to help authorities track and verify workers more effectively.
“In this case, the migrant labours who were from West Bengal came to Bengaluru in search of job, entered the house of deceased persons as maid, they made criminal conspiracy, committed murder of deceased persons (three deaths) and robbed gold, silver and other valuable properties in their house and fled away. They were arrested after twenty months of the incident … there was difficulty in tracing and securing the accused persons. In this regard, streamlining of the aforesaid guidelines is very much required. Thus, we hereby direct the State Government to take a call on this issue,”
the judgment said.
The Bench directed that a copy of its observations be sent to the Chief Secretary of the Karnataka government so that the State can consider framing appropriate guidelines for background verification and safe hiring practices.
High Court Government Pleader Rashmi Patel represented the State in the matter, while Advocate GR Sheshadri appeared on behalf of the accused persons.
Case Title:
State of Karnataka v. Deepak Haldar and ors
Click Here to Read Our Reports on Domestic Workers
