Rejecting the pleas of parity with a co-accused and prolonged custody, the Delhi High Court has refused regular bail to a man accused of opening fire in a gym in 2018, noting that the defence counsel did not turn up to cross-examine the injured despite specific dates, and cautioning against a practice of protracting the trial and then relying on its delay to seek bail; the case is yet to be tried.

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has dismissed the regular bail application of Sanam Dagar, accused in FIR No. 232 of 2018 registered at Police Station Bawana for offences under Sections 307, 120B, 174A and 34 of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act, holding that no case for bail was made out at this stage [Sanam Dagar v. State (NCT of Delhi)].
Justice Girish Kathpalia delivered the oral judgment on September 30, 2026 after hearing counsel for the applicant and the Additional Public Prosecutor, assisted by the Investigating Officer, Inspector Ajay Kumar.
The prosecution’s case
The prosecution alleges that the applicant and his associates entered a gym and opened fire. Of six or seven rounds fired, three hit the injured person. The incident was captured on CCTV, and the footage was played in court, where, according to the Court, it shows the applicant, in an orange t-shirt, firing a pistol. These are allegations and are yet to be proved at trial.
Grounds for bail
Counsel for the applicant raised two grounds: that co-accused Sumit @ Kalu had been granted bail, and that the applicant had been in jail for a long time. During dictation, counsel added that the public witnesses had been examined.
The Additional Public Prosecutor submitted that the defence was responsible for the delay in trial. It was pointed out that, even after the last order in the bail application, the defence counsel did not appear when the injured, Monu, came to the trial court for cross-examination. It was also submitted that the applicant remained a Proclaimed Offender for more than a year, which delayed the proceedings.
No parity with co-accused
On parity, the Court held that the role attributed to co-accused Sumit @ Kalu is distinct from that attributed to the applicant. The three bullet injuries to the injured were caused by the pistol fired by the applicant, whereas, as submitted by the Additional Public Prosecutor, the pistol of Sumit, though he tried to use it, jammed and could not function.
Prolonged custody and delay in trial
On the plea of long custody, the Court recorded a wider concern about how delay is used as a ground for bail:
“As regards prolonged custody of the accused/applicant, it is being observed in a number of cases that initially the defence counsel would somehow protract the trial and thereafter raise the delay in trial as a ground for bail. Such misuse of process has to be understood in its proper perspective.”
Applying this to the case, the Court noted that counsel for the applicant did not place the trial court’s ordersheets on record to show that the defence was not responsible for the time taken by the trial. Instead, despite the discussion on these lines in the last order, the defence counsel stayed away from cross-examining the injured when he appeared before the trial court. On the last hearing of the bail application, this Court had itself fixed September 14, 2026 as the date for his cross-examination in the presence of both sides, yet the defence counsel again did not appear before the trial court.
Public witnesses and the CCTV footage
Dealing with the argument that the public witnesses had been examined, the Court said the unchallenged testimony of the injured stared it in the face, and that the manner in which the offence allegedly took place was clearly depicted in the CCTV footage, which could not be ignored. Finding it not a fit case for bail at this stage, the Court dismissed the application.
Why the order matters
The order shows that a plea of long incarceration does not automatically carry an accused to bail where the record suggests that the defence has contributed to the delay, and that a bailed co-accused’s release will not help another accused whose alleged role is different. It also signals that the accused’s conduct in the trial court, including non-appearance for cross-examination and a period as a proclaimed offender, may be weighed when delay is pressed as a ground. The observations are made only for deciding the bail application and the applicant is presumed innocent until proved guilty.
Case Title: Sanam Dagar v. State (NCT of Delhi) [Bail Appln. 2834/2026]
Bench: Justice Girish Kathpalia, Delhi High Court
Date of Judgment: September 30, 2026
Appearances: Advocates Parveen Tyagi (through video conferencing), Vaibhav Tyagi and Harsh Maan for the applicant; Additional Public Prosecutor Manjeet Arya with Inspector Ajay Kumar for the State
