Calcutta High Court Questions Bilaspur FRO’s Move To Decide Citizenship During Pendency Of SIR Appeals

3 min read

Can an authority rule on a man’s citizenship while his appeal over the electoral roll is still alive before a tribunal? The Calcutta High Court put that question to the Foreigners Registration Officer, who is also the Superintendent of Police, Bilaspur, in a matter concerning four Murshidabad men detained on suspicion of being illegal immigrants. The suspicion is untested.

Justice Krishna Rao of the Calcutta High Court, who questioned the Bilaspur FRO over deciding citizenship during pending SIR appeals

Kolkata: The Calcutta High Court has questioned the Foreigners Registration Officer (FRO), who is also the Superintendent of Police, Bilaspur, over the authority’s move to determine the citizenship of four men from Murshidabad while their appeals against deletion of their names from the electoral roll during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) are pending before the appellate tribunal. The Court has made no finding on the citizenship of the men, who are detained on suspicion of being illegal immigrants from Bangladesh, and the suspicion is untested. [Mostakim Sheikh Petition]

Justice Krishna Rao raised the issue during the hearing of a petition filed by Mostakim Sheikh, a resident of Hiranandapur village in Samserganj, Murshidabad.

A pointed line of questioning

Justice Rao wanted to know how the FRO could decide the nationality of the men at the very time the tribunal was seized of their appeals. He called the situation “contradictory” and asked what the pending appeal would amount to if the authorities went ahead and decided citizenship in parallel.

According to the account of the hearing, the Court put these questions to the authorities:

“What is the duty of your authorities? What is the duty of the tribunal? If your authorities are simultaneously deciding it, then I will pass an order referring the matter to Supreme Court.”

Justice Rao followed up with this remark:

“If your authority is telling that he is not an Indian, so what will the appellate authority do? You are playing with people.”

The tribunal, the Court also noted, was “actively hearing” the appeals. Justice Rao again asked what would become of an appeal once the FRO had settled the question of citizenship in the meantime. What the authorities said in reply to these remarks has not been reported.

The petition and the petitioner

Mostakim Sheikh describes himself as a neighbour of the four men. His petition asks for expeditious consideration of their appeals before the SIR appellate tribunal. His case is that the four have challenged the deletion of their names from the electoral roll before the tribunal constituted pursuant to the Supreme Court’s directions.

For over a month, the four have been held in Bilaspur on suspicion of being illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. Counsel for the petitioner submitted that all four appear in the 2002 SIR electoral roll and also voted in the 2026 West Bengal Assembly elections. These are the petitioner’s submissions, and they have not been tested.

FRO to be brought on record

The Court was told that the four men had been detained by the FRO, who had not been made a party to the proceedings. It directed the petitioner’s counsel to implead the FRO, and asked the office for a report on the detention.

The matter is to be listed next on October 8. The Court has expressed no view on the merits of the appeals before the tribunal, or on the nationality of the four men.

Case Details: Mostakim Sheikh Petition | Court: Calcutta High Court | Bench: Justice Krishna Rao | Next listing: October 8 (FRO to be impleaded; report sought on detention). Case number and cause title not reported. Allegations and suspicions untested; no finding on citizenship.

Appearances: Counsel for the petitioner (name not reported).

Similar Posts