The Madhya Pradesh High Court has called the State’s pleadings “callous and irresponsible” after finding fictitious AI-generated case law in its reply, and has set aside a police officer’s summary dismissal.

Jabalpur: A Supreme Court judgment that does not exist, cited in the State government’s reply, has drawn a sharp rebuke from the Madhya Pradesh High Court, which held that the State had “blindly resorted” to Artificial Intelligence tools and quashed the 2024 dismissal of an Acting Sub-Inspector who was thrown out of service without any departmental enquiry [Piyush Mani Tiwari v. The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others].
Allowing the writ petition on November 17, 2026, Justice Vivek Kumar Singh directed that the petitioner be reinstated forthwith and sent a copy of the order to the Principal Secretary, Law, and the Advocate General of Madhya Pradesh.
Suspended one day, dismissed the next
The petitioner joined the Madhya Pradesh Police as a Constable in December 1992 and, in May 2024, was serving as an Acting Sub-Inspector in the Special Branch at Police Headquarters, Bhopal. A complaint by a woman employee was received on May 26, 2024. He was suspended the same day and dismissed the very next day, on May 27, 2024, under Article 311(1) read with Articles 311(2)(b) and 311(3) of the Constitution and Clause 222(c) of the Madhya Pradesh Police Regulations. His departmental appeal was rejected on July 22, 2024.
The State argued that an enquiry was not reasonably practicable because the complaint involved a woman employee, prolonging the matter could cause distress and public outrage, immediate action was needed to keep public trust and discipline in the force, and the petitioner’s position created a likelihood of witness intimidation.
Why the Article 311(2)(b) route failed
None of these grounds, the Court held, met the constitutional threshold under Article 311(2)(b), and it found nothing on record to show that the petitioner had threatened or intimidated the complainant or any witness. He was dismissed without even a preliminary enquiry or a show-cause notice, although, having already been suspended and attached to the Special Branch Line, there was no impediment to serving a charge-sheet and holding a regular enquiry under Rule 14 of the M.P. Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966.
The dismissal order of May 27, 2024 and the appellate order of July 22, 2024 were quashed. The State is free to hold a regular departmental enquiry under the 1966 Rules after giving the petitioner a reasonable opportunity of hearing, and back wages and other benefits for the intervening period will abide by its outcome. The Court made clear that it has expressed no opinion on the merits of the allegations against the petitioner.
A fabricated authority in the State’s reply
To argue that the High Court could not re-appreciate evidence under Article 226, the State relied heavily on a purported Supreme Court ruling titled “State of Andhra Pradesh vs. S.S. Mohammad Nisar”, cited as (2008) 5 SCC 230. The Court found that no such judgment exists. The citation actually belongs to Sidhartha Vashisht @ Manu Sharma vs. State (NCT of Delhi), a case on suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal.
“It is glaringly apparent that the respondents have blindly resorted to the use of Artificial Intelligence tools to draft their pleadings, resulting in the incorporation of a fabricated case name cross-wired with an unrelated citation.”
“Pleadings filed before a Constitutional Court are solemn documents. The casual insertion of fictitious case laws without undertaking the basic professional duty of cross-checking the citations not only wastes precious judicial time but also borders on actively misleading the Court. The respondents and the State machinery are strictly cautioned against such reckless practices.”
The Court added that the office of the Advocate General is expected to ensure that all legal propositions and citations are meticulously verified by the drafting counsel before they are sworn on affidavit and placed on record.
Why the judgment matters
AI-generated fake citations have so far mostly been flagged in orders of tribunals and authorities, or in filings by private litigants. Here the fabricated authority came from the State itself, in a sworn reply before a constitutional court, and the High Court has placed the duty to verify squarely on the Advocate General’s office and the drafting counsel.
On service law, the ruling restates that Article 311(2)(b) is an exception, to be used only when an enquiry is genuinely not reasonably practicable and material on record supports it. The seriousness of a complaint, or the general fear of witness pressure, does not by itself justify dismissing an employee overnight without a hearing.
Case Title: Piyush Mani Tiwari v. The State of Madhya Pradesh & Others [Writ Petition No. 27922 of 2024], 2026:MPHC-JBP:91141
Bench: Justice Vivek Kumar Singh, Madhya Pradesh High Court, Jabalpur
Reserved on: November 5, 2026
Date of Order: November 17, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Nityanand Mishra for the petitioner; Government Advocate Swati Aseem George for the State
