Did all three Election Commissioners really agree on the SIR? Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders want the Election Commission of India to answer 48 written questions on affidavit to test its claim that the decisions were unanimous, and have asked the Supreme Court for permission to serve them. The Court has not yet ruled on the application.

New Delhi: An application in the Supreme Court asks for leave to serve 48 interrogatories on the Election Commission of India (ECI) over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. It has been moved by Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and other INDIA bloc leaders [Rahul Gandhi and Others v. Election Commission of India and Others].
Interrogatories are formal written questions which the opposite party must answer on oath. According to reports, the application, filed in the INDIA bloc’s pending writ petition against the Commission, invokes Order V Rule 1, Order XXXVIII Rule 11(9) and Order LV Rule 6 of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013.
Unanimous, says the Commission; undisclosed, say the petitioners
The petitioners say the core issue is whether Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar exercised the Commission’s collective powers “without the knowledge, approval, or concurrence” of the other two Election Commissioners, Dr Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Dr Vivek Joshi.
The Commission’s counter-affidavit dated October 26 and supplementary affidavit dated November 14, both affirmed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu, state that the SIR orders followed “unanimous decisions of the three-member body.” The application argues that these affidavits rely on “bare assertions while withholding crucial official files and records,” and do not disclose the file numbers, dates or minutes of meetings at which the decisions were taken. The petitioners also rely on an August 2025 RTI reply which said that “no decision had been taken to initiate a nationwide SIR.”
The Commission has not yet responded to the application. In its affidavits, it has said that its three SIR orders, dated June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026, were passed unanimously. It has also said that the Chief Election Commissioner did not act unilaterally, and that a query or note recorded by a Commissioner on a file is not by itself a decision of the Commission. Urgent matters, it has said, are approved electronically and recorded on file later, and the declaration added during the SIR is not part of the statutory Form 6.
Ten categories, 48 questions
The questions are grouped into ten categories. Reports on the application describe the main areas as follows.
- The SIR decision: when and how the nationwide SIR was adopted, whether all three Commissioners agreed, and the file, noting sheets and meeting at which the claimed consensus was recorded.
- Dissent by Commissioners: the two Election Commissioners are asked to disclose “every occasion between February 2025 and October 2026 on which they recorded written objections, dissents, or reservations” concerning the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 or the Commission’s appeals in court, and whether any decision was taken by majority.
- ECINET and ERONET: about 15 technical questions for the Director General (IT), including “whether private contractors or vendors had write access to the electoral-roll database,” whether “bulk deletions occurred without orders from Electoral Registration Officers,” whether audit logs are kept, and what action followed Dr Vivek Joshi‘s proposal for an access audit.
- Form 6: “who authorised inserting a new declaration into online Form 6,” when it was approved, how many online applications have since been rejected or left pending, and “state-wise data on voters dropped from draft and final rolls.”
- Approvals and appeals: “whether urgent ECI approvals were obtained via WhatsApp or personal email,” and who decided to file the Commission’s appeals against court orders on inclusion of names in West Bengal.
Who would answer
According to reports, the application proposes that Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu give factual answers to all 48 questions. The Chief Election Commissioner and the two Election Commissioners would file sworn affidavits on questions about their personal or collective consent, and the Director General (IT) would answer the technical questions on ECINET.
If the Commission claims privilege over any official record, the application asks that it be directed to “state the specific grounds for each record for the Court’s adjudication.”
The Puttaswamy argument
The petitioners rely on the Constitution Bench judgment in Justice KS Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India, the Aadhaar case. They argue that where facts central to a constitutional challenge lie “within the exclusive knowledge” of an authority running a technological system, the Court may require its officials to answer specific questions.
Where the petition stands
The writ petition, W.P.(C) No. 1351 of 2026, was filed on October 12 by Rahul Gandhi, Mallikarjun Kharge and leaders of other Opposition parties. On October 15, a Bench led by CJI Surya Kant issued notice to the Commission, the Chief Election Commissioner and the two Election Commissioners. The petition seeks, among other things, production of the Commission’s files and minutes, an audit of deletions by a committee headed by a retired Supreme Court judge, and booth-wise publication of deleted voters with reasons.
A related petition by Rakesh Kumar Singh raising similar allegations is pending before the same Bench. On October 27, the Court gave the petitioners in the batch two weeks to file rejoinders and listed the petitions on November 17. Whether the interrogatories application will be taken up on that date was not known.
Why the application matters
Writ petitions in the Supreme Court are usually decided on affidavits, and interrogatories are rarely allowed in them. If the Court permits the questions, the Election Commissioners may have to state on oath whether they dissented from SIR decisions, which would go to the heart of the dispute over whether the Commission acted as a multi-member body. If it declines, the case will turn on the Commission’s affidavits and any records the Court calls for.
The allegations are the petitioners’ contentions, the Commission disputes them, and the Court has expressed no view on the merits.
Case Title: Rahul Gandhi and Others v. Election Commission of India and Others
Case No.: W.P.(C) No. 1351 of 2026
Application: Seeking leave to serve 48 interrogatories on the respondents
Bench: Led by CJI Surya Kant
Batch listed: November 17, 2026
