The Kerala High Court dismissed the criminal case against Dr. Joseph John, emphasizing that patient deaths do not always indicate medical negligence. The court underscored the necessity of proof of gross negligence for criminal liability, reinforcing that doctors should not be unjustly blamed for outcomes resulting from the nature of the ailments.
The Supreme Court ruled that Manipal Hospital must compensate Rs.10 lakh for a trainee doctor’s anesthesia error, highlighting medical procedure accountability and patient safety. The widow of the deceased sought relief, leading to the Court’s decision. Despite initial compensation of ₹5,00,000, the Court deemed it insufficient and directed immediate payment of ₹10 lakh.
