While reacting to the controversy over Chief Justice’s nephew recommended for High Court judge post, Ex-SC Judge Abhay S. Oka said CJI must distance himself and any judge should step aside if their relative’s name comes up in the collegium.
Senior Advocate Vikas Pahwa has appealed to CJI BR Gavai to halt the proposed transfers of Justices Arun Monga and Tara Vitasta Ganju, citing their outstanding contributions at Delhi High Court. He emphasized that their relocation could impact timely justice delivery and public confidence in the judiciary.
The Delhi High Court will hear a plea on September 3 challenging the Lieutenant Governor’s order that allows police officials to record evidence virtually from police stations, amid the ongoing strike by lawyers in the capital’s district judiciary.
SCAORA has “unanimously and strongly condemned” the Delhi LG’s notification declaring police stations as venues for recording testimony. Lawyers warn it threatens judicial independence and public trust.
The Supreme Court expressed anguish after an NCLAT judge revealed that a revered higher judiciary member allegedly sought a favourable order. Directing a probe, the Court stressed that such influence threatens judicial independence, fairness, and integrity of legal proceedings.
The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) has strongly opposed the Delhi LG’s notification designating police stations for recording evidence of police officials. SCBA calls the move “arbitrary, unlawful, and against natural justice.”
Today, On 11th August, The Supreme Court criticised the growing “trend among lawyers to critique judges of HC and trial courts,” noting that in political cases, there is often an assumption that justice cannot be delivered in the High Court.
Former SC judge Abhay Oka said the collegium system has flaws, but any replacement must be a better alternative. He also spoke on judicial independence, media’s role, and environmental protection.
Former Supreme Court judge Abhay Oka refused to comment on the merits of the Yashwant Varma case, citing his role in the decision-making process. He stressed the need to protect judges from frivolous FIRs to safeguard judicial independence.
The Allahabad High Court Bar Association praised the Supreme Court for deleting its earlier critical remarks against Justice Prashant Kumar, calling it a step to protect judicial independence. The SC clarified it never intended to embarrass the judge and acted to uphold the judiciary’s dignity.
