The Supreme Court said that a long offence-free period can justify reducing sentences in minor, non-violent cases. In the 1995 house-breaking matter, the three-month sentence was reduced to the 15 days already undergone.
The Supreme Court acquitted Manoj alias Munna in a 2004 Chhattisgarh murder case, holding that suspicion cannot replace proof. The Court ruled that “last seen” evidence alone is too weak to justify a life imprisonment conviction.
The Supreme Court held that circumstantial evidence can justify a conviction only when it is completely inconsistent with the accused’s innocence. The Court ruled that conviction cannot be based solely on the “last seen together” theory without strong corroborative proof.
The Kerala High Court has ruled that circumstantial evidence is sufficient to establish adultery in maintenance proceedings under Section 125 CrPC. The Court denied maintenance to a wife after concluding habitual adulterous behaviour.
The Supreme Court acquitted three in a 2006 policeman murder case, ruling that a conviction cannot stand when the evidence chain is incomplete, the motive unproven, and disclosure statements unreliable.
The Supreme Court set aside a woman’s conviction for killing her infant son, holding that extra-judicial confessions were weak and circumstantial evidence did not prove guilt. The Court said such an act defies a mother’s natural instinct.
Calcutta High Court commuted the death penalty of two convicts found guilty of raping a child, sentencing them to 60 years in prison. The Court said their acts showed “depravity that shocks the conscience,” demanding serious punishment.
The Supreme Court ruled that a accused cannot be convicted based solely on circumstantial evidence. It further stated that the present matter was clearly a case built entirely on circumstantial evidence.
Bombay: A sessions court in Panvel, Maharashtra, on Monday sentenced former police inspector Abhay Kurundkar to life imprisonment for the murder of assistant police inspector (API) Ashwini Bidre-Gore in 2016. Kurundkar, who had received the prestigious President’s medal in 2017, was found guilty of killing Bidre-Gore, with whom he was allegedly in a relationship.
A Kolkata court criticized police and RG Kar Medical College for mishandling a rape and murder case. Despite these lapses, Sanjay Roy was sentenced to life imprisonment. The court ruled out the death penalty, emphasizing the need for justice grounded in evidence and legal principles rather than public sentiment.
